Public inspection of written determinations

26 U.S.C. § 6110
in effect
Sign in to generate a plain English summaryAsk Belisarius Agent
(a) General ruleExcept as otherwise provided in this section, the text of any written determination and any background file document relating to such written determination shall be open to public inspection at such place as the Secretary may by regulations prescribe. (b) DefinitionsFor purposes of this section—(1) Written determination(A) In generalThe term “written determination” means a ruling, determination letter, technical advice memorandum, or Chief Counsel advice. (B) ExceptionsSuch term shall not include any matter referred to in subparagraph (C) or (D) of section 6103(b)(2). (2) Background file documentThe term “background file document” with respect to a written determination includes the request for that written determination, any written material submitted in support of the request, and any communication (written or otherwise) between the Internal Revenue Service and persons outside the Internal Revenue Service in connection with such written determination (other than any communication between the Department of Justice and the Internal Revenue Service relating to a pending civil or criminal case or investigation) received before issuance of the written determination. (3) Reference and general written determinations(A) Reference written determinationThe term “reference written determination” means any written determination which has been determined by the Secretary to have significant reference value. (B) General written determinationThe term “general written determination” means any written determination other than a reference written determination. (c) Exemptions from disclosureBefore making any written determination or background file document open or available to public inspection under subsection (a), the Secretary shall delete—(1) the names, addresses, and other identifying details of the person to whom the written determination pertains and of any other person, other than a person with respect to whom a notation is made under subsection (d)(1), identified in the written determination or any background file document; (2) information specifically authorized under criteria established by an Executive order to be kept secret in the interest of national defense or foreign policy, and which is in fact properly classified pursuant to such Executive order; (3) information specifically exempted from disclosure by any statute (other than this title) which is applicable to the Internal Revenue Service; (4) trade secrets and commercial or financial information obtained from a person and privileged or confidential; (5) information the disclosure of which would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy; (6) information contained in or related to examination, operating, or condition reports prepared by, or on behalf of, or for use of an agency responsible for the regulation or supervision of financial institutions; and (7) geological and geophysical information and data, including maps, concerning wells. The Secretary shall determine the appropriate extent of such deletions and, except in the case of intentional or willful disregard of this subsection, shall not be required to make such deletions (nor be liable for failure to make deletions) unless the Secretary has agreed to such deletions or has been ordered by a court (in a proceeding under subsection (f)(3)) to make such deletions. (d) Procedures with regard to third party contacts(1) NotationsIf, before the issuance of a written determination, the Internal Revenue Service receives any communication (written or otherwise) concerning such written determination, any request for such determination, or any other matter involving such written determination from a person other than an employee of the Internal Revenue Service or the person to whom such written determination pertains (or his authorized representative with regard to such written determination), the Internal Revenue Service shall indicate, on the written determination open to public inspection, the category of the person making such communication and the date of such communication. (2) ExceptionParagraph (1) shall not apply to any communication made by the Chief of Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation. (3) Disclosure of identityIn the case of any written determination to which paragraph (1) applies, any person may file a petition in the United States Tax Court or file a complaint in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia for an order requiring that the identity of any person to whom the written determination pertains be disclosed. The court shall order disclosure of such identity if there is evidence in the record from which one could reasonably conclude that an impropriety occurred or undue influence was exercised with respect to such written determination by or on behalf of such person. The court may also direct the Secretary to disclose any portion of any other deletions made in accordance with subsection (c) where such disclosure is in the public interest. If a proceeding is commenced under this paragraph, the person whose identity is subject to being disclosed and the person about whom a notation is made under paragraph (1) shall be notified of the proceeding in accordance with the procedures described in subsection (f)(4)(B) and shall have the right to intervene in the proceeding (anonymously, if appropriate). (4) Period in which to bring actionNo proceeding shall be commenced under paragraph (3) unless a petition is filed before the expiration of 36 months after the first day that the written determination is open to public inspection. (e) Background file documentsWhenever the Secretary makes a written determination open to public inspection under this section, he shall also make available to any person, but only upon the written request of that person, any background file document relating to the written determination. (f) Resolution of disputes relating to disclosure(1) Notice of intention to discloseExcept as otherwise provided by subsection (i), the Secretary shall upon issuance of any written determination, or upon receipt of a request for a background file document, mail a notice of intention to disclose such determination or document to any person to whom the written determination pertains (or a successor in interest, executor, or other person authorized by law to act for or on behalf of such person). (2) Administrative remediesThe Secretary shall prescribe regulations establishing administrative remedies with respect to—(A) requests for additional disclosure of any written determination of any background file document, and (B) requests to restrain disclosure. (3) Action to restrain disclosure(A) Creation of remedyAny person—(i) to whom a written determination pertains (or a successor in interest, executor, or other person authorized by law to act for or on behalf of such person), or who has a direct interest in maintaining the confidentiality of any such written determination or background file document (or portion thereof), (ii) who disagrees with any failure to make a deletion with respect to that portion of any written determination or any background file document which is to be open or available to public inspection, and (iii) who has exhausted his administrative remedies as prescribed pursuant to paragraph (2), may, within 60 days after the mailing by the Secretary of a notice of intention to disclose any written determination or background file document under paragraph (1), together with the proposed deletions, file a petition in the United States Tax Court (anonymously, if appropriate) for a determination with respect to that portion of such written determination or background file document which is to be open to public inspection. (B) Notice to certain personsThe Secretary shall notify any person to whom a written determination pertains (unless such person is the petitioner) of the filing of a petition under this paragraph with respect to such written determination or related background file document, and any such person may intervene (anonymously, if appropriate) in any proceeding conducted pursuant to this paragraph. The Secretary shall send such notice by registered or certified mail to the last known address of such person within 15 days after such petition is served on the Secretary. No person who has received such a notice may thereafter file any petition under this paragraph with respect to such written determination or background file document with respect to which such notice was received. (4) Action to obtain additional disclosure(A) Creation of remedyAny person who has exhausted the administrative remedies prescribed pursuant to paragraph (2) with respect to a request for disclosure may file a petition in the United States Tax Court or a complaint in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia for an order requiring that any written determination or background file document (or portion thereof) be made open or available to public inspection. Except where inconsistent with subparagraph (B), the provisions of subparagraphs (C), (D), (E), (F), and (G) of section 552(a)(4) of title 5, United States Code, shall apply to any proceeding under this paragraph. The Court shall examine the matter de novo and without regard to a decision of a court under paragraph (3) with respect to such written determination or background file document, and may examine the entire text of such written determination or background file document in order to determine whether such written determination or background file document or any part thereof shall be open or available to public inspection under this section. The burden of proof with respect to the issue of disclosure of any information shall be on the Secretary and any other person seeking to restrain disclosure. (B) InterventionIf a proceeding is commenced under this paragraph with respect to any written determination or background file document, the Secretary shall, within 15 days after notice of the petition filed under subparagraph (A) is served on him, send notice of the commencement of such proceeding to all persons who are identified by name and address in such written determination or background file document. The Secretary shall send such notice by registered or certified mail to the last known address of such person. Any person to whom such determination or background file document pertains may intervene in the proceeding (anonymously, if appropriate). If such notice is sent, the Secretary shall not be required to defend the action and shall not be liable for public disclosure of the written determination or background file document (or any portion thereof) in accordance with the final decision of the court. (5) Expedition of determinationThe Tax Court shall make a decision with respect to any petition described in paragraph (3) at the earliest practicable date. (6) Publicity of Tax Court proceedingsNotwithstanding sections 7458 and 7461, the Tax Court may, in order to preserve the anonymity, privacy, or confidentiality of any person under this section, provide by rules adopted under section 7453 that portions of hearings, testimony, evidence, and reports in connection with proceedings under this section may be closed to the public or to inspection by the public. (g) Time for disclosure(1) In generalExcept as otherwise provided in this section, the text of any written determination or any background file document (as modified under subsection (c)) shall be open or available to public inspection—(A) no earlier than 75 days, and no later than 90 days, after the notice provided in subsection (f)(1) is mailed, or, if later, (B) within 30 days after the date on which a court decision under subsection (f)(3) becomes final. (2) Postponement by order of courtThe court may extend the period referred to in paragraph (1)(B) for such time as the court finds necessary to allow the Secretary to comply with its decision. (3) Postponement of disclosure for up to 90 daysAt the written request of the person by whom or on whose behalf the request for the written determination was made, the period referred to in paragraph (1)(A) shall be extended (for not to exceed an additional 90 days) until the day which is 15 days after the date of the Secretary’s determination that the transaction set forth in the written determination has been completed. (4) Additional 180 daysIf—(A) the transaction set forth in the written determination is not completed during the period set forth in paragraph (3), and (B) the person by whom or on whose behalf the request for the written determination was made establishes to the satisfaction of the Secretary that good cause exists for additional delay in opening the written determination to public inspection, the period referred to in paragraph (3) shall be further extended (for not to exceed an additional 180 days) until the day which is 15 days after the date of the Secretary’s determination that the transaction set forth in the written determination has been completed. (5) Special rules for certain written determinations, etc.Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (1), the Secretary shall not be required to make available to the public—(A) any technical advice memorandum, any Chief Counsel advice, and any related background file document involving any matter which is the subject of a civil fraud or criminal investigation or jeopardy or termination assessment until after any action relating to such investigation or assessment is completed, or (B) any general written determination and any related background file document that relates solely to approval of the Secretary of any adoption or change of—(i) the funding method or plan year of a plan under section 412, (ii) a taxpayer’s annual accounting period under section 442, (iii) a taxpayer’s method of accounting under section 446(e), or (iv) a partnership’s or partner’s taxable year under section 706, but the Secretary shall make any such written determination and related background file document available upon the written request of any person after the date on which (except for this subparagraph) such determination would be open to public inspection. (h) Disclosure of prior written determinations and related background file documents(1) In generalExcept as otherwise provided in this subsection, a written determination issued pursuant to a request made before November 1, 1976, and any background file document relating to such written determination shall be open or available to public inspection in accordance with this section. (2) Time for disclosureIn the case of any written determination or background file document which is to be made open or available to public inspection under paragraph (1)—(A) subsection (g) shall not apply, but (B) such written determination or background file document shall be made open or available to public inspection at the earliest practicable date after funds for that purpose have been appropriated and made available to the Internal Revenue Service. (3) Order of releaseAny written determination or background file document described in paragraph (1) shall be open or available to public inspection in the following order starting with the most recent written determination in each category:(A) reference written determinations issued under this title; (B) general written determinations issued after July 4, 1967; and (C) reference written determinations issued under the Internal Revenue Code of 1939 or corresponding provisions of prior law. General written determinations not described in subparagraph (B) shall be open to public inspection on written request, but not until after the written determinations referred to in subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) are open to public inspection. (4) Notice that prior written determinations are open to public inspectionNotwithstanding the provisions of subsections (f)(1) and (f)(3)(A), not less than 90 days before making any portion of a written determination described in this subsection open to public inspection, the Secretary shall issue public notice in the Federal Register that such written determination is to be made open to public inspection. The person who received a written determination may, within 75 days after the date of publication of notice under this paragraph, file a petition in the United States Tax Court (anonymously, if appropriate) for a determination with respect to that portion of such written determination which is to be made open to public inspection. The provisions of subsections (f)(3)(B), (5), and (6) shall apply if such a petition is filed. If no petition is filed, the text of any written determination shall be open to public inspection no earlier than 90 days, and no later than 120 days, after notice is published in the Federal Register. (5) ExclusionSubsection (d) shall not apply to any written determination described in paragraph (1). (i) Special rules for disclosure of Chief Counsel advice(1) Chief Counsel advice defined(A) In generalFor purposes of this section, the term “Chief Counsel advice” means written advice or instruction, under whatever name or designation, prepared by any national office component of the Office of Chief Counsel which—(i) is issued to field or service center employees of the Service or regional or district employees of the Office of Chief Counsel; and (ii) conveys—(I) any legal interpretation of a revenue provision; (II) any Internal Revenue Service or Office of Chief Counsel position or policy concerning a revenue provision; or (III) any legal interpretation of State law, foreign law, or other Federal law relating to the assessment or collection of any liability under a revenue provision. (B) Revenue provision definedFor purposes of subparagraph (A), the term “revenue provision” means any existing or former internal revenue law, regulation, revenue ruling, revenue procedure, other published or unpublished guidance, or tax treaty, either in general or as applied to specific taxpayers or groups of specific taxpayers. (2) Additional documents treated as Chief Counsel adviceThe Secretary may by regulation provide that this section shall apply to any advice or instruction prepared and issued by the Office of Chief Counsel which is not described in paragraph (1). (3) Deletions for Chief Counsel adviceIn the case of Chief Counsel advice and related background file documents open to public inspection pursuant to this section—(A) paragraphs (2) through (7) of subsection (c) shall not apply, but (B) the Secretary may make deletions of material in accordance with subsections (b) and (c) of section 552 of title 5, United States Code, except that in applying subsection (b)(3) of such section, no statutory provision of this title shall be taken into account. (4) Notice of intention to disclose(A) Nontaxpayer-specific Chief Counsel adviceIn the case of Chief Counsel advice which is written without reference to a specific taxpayer or group of specific taxpayers—(i) subsection (f)(1) shall not apply; and (ii) the Secretary shall, within 60 days after the issuance of the Chief Counsel advice, complete any deletions described in subsection (c)(1) or paragraph (3) and make the Chief Counsel advice, as so edited, open for public inspection. (B) Taxpayer-specific Chief Counsel adviceIn the case of Chief Counsel advice which is written with respect to a specific taxpayer or group of specific taxpayers, the Secretary shall, within 60 days after the issuance of the Chief Counsel advice, mail the notice required by subsection (f)(1) to each such taxpayer. The notice shall include a copy of the Chief Counsel advice on which is indicated the information that the Secretary proposes to delete pursuant to subsection (c)(1). The Secretary may also delete from the copy of the text of the Chief Counsel advice any of the information described in paragraph (3), and shall delete the names, addresses, and other identifying details of taxpayers other than the person to whom the advice pertains, except that the Secretary shall not delete from the copy of the Chief Counsel advice that is furnished to the taxpayer any information of which that taxpayer was the source. (j) Civil remedies(1) Civil actionWhenever the Secretary—(A) fails to make deletions required in accordance with subsection (c), or (B) fails to follow the procedures in subsection (g) or (i)(4)(B), the recipient of the written determination or any person identified in the written determination shall have as an exclusive civil remedy an action against the Secretary in the United States Court of Federal Claims, which shall have jurisdiction to hear any action under this paragraph. (2) DamagesIn any suit brought under the provisions of paragraph (1)(A) in which the Court determines that an employee of the Internal Revenue Service intentionally or willfully failed to delete in accordance with subsection (c), or in any suit brought under subparagraph (1)(B) in which the Court determines that an employee intentionally or willfully failed to act in accordance with subsection (g) or (i)(4)(B), the United States shall be liable to the person in an amount equal to the sum of—(A) actual damages sustained by the person but in no case shall a person be entitled to receive less than the sum of $1,000, and (B) the costs of the action together with reasonable attorney’s fees as determined by the Court. (k) Special provisions(1) FeesThe Secretary is authorized to assess actual costs—(A) for duplication of any written determination or background file document made open or available to the public under this section, and (B) incurred in searching for and making deletions required under subsection (c)(1) or (i)(3) from any written determination or background file document which is available to public inspection only upon written request. The Secretary shall furnish any written determination or background file document without charge or at a reduced charge if he determines that waiver or reduction of the fee is in the public interest because furnishing such determination or background file document can be considered as primarily benefiting the general public. (2) Records disposal proceduresNothing in this section shall prevent the Secretary from disposing of any general written determination or background file document described in subsection (b) in accordance with established records disposition procedures, but such disposal shall, except as provided in the following sentence, occur not earlier than 3 years after such written determination is first made open to public inspection. In the case of any general written determination described in subsection (h), the Secretary may dispose of such determination and any related background file document in accordance with such procedures but such disposal shall not occur earlier than 3 years after such written determination is first made open to public inspection if funds are appropriated for such purpose before January 20, 1979, or not earlier than January 20, 1979, if funds are not appropriated before such date. The Secretary shall not dispose of any reference written determinations and related background file documents. (3) Precedential statusUnless the Secretary otherwise establishes by regulations, a written determination may not be used or cited as precedent. The preceding sentence shall not apply to change the precedential status (if any) of written determinations with regard to taxes imposed by subtitle D of this title. (l) Section not to applyThis section shall not apply to—(1) any matter to which section 6104 or 6105 applies, or (2) any—(A) written determination issued pursuant to a request made before November 1, 1976, with respect to the exempt status under section 501(a) of an organization described in section 501(c) or (d), the status of an organization as a private foundation under section 509(a), or the status of an organization as an operating foundation under section 4942(j)(3), (B) written determination described in subsection (g)(5)(B) issued pursuant to a request made before November 1, 1976, (C) determination letter not otherwise described in subparagraph (A), (B), or (E) issued pursuant to a request made before November 1, 1976, (D) background file document relating to any general written determination issued before July 5, 1967, or (E) letter or other document described in section 6104(a)(1)(B)(iv) issued before September 2, 1974 . (m) Exclusive remedyExcept as otherwise provided in this title, or with respect to a discovery order made in connection with a judicial proceeding, the Secretary shall not be required by any Court to make any written determination or background file document open or available to public inspection, or to refrain from disclosure of any such documents.