§ 2-120.22 - Criteria for certificate of review.
The following criteria shall be the basis on which City Council considers approval or disapproval of an application for a certificate of review depending on the nature of the construction, demolition, relocation or alteration. The criteria contained in the United States Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings, shall provide specific details and shall take precedence over any other conflicting criteria.
(a) New construction.
(1) New construction shall be designed and constructed to be clearly differentiated from but visually compatible with the buildings and environment with which it is visually related, including, but not limited to, the height and floor-to-area ratio, the proportion between width and height of the exterior, the relationship of solids to voids created by openings in the exterior, the materials used in the exterior, the texture inherent in the exterior, the design of the roof and the relationship of building masses and spaces between them.
(2) The construction of an exterior addition to an historic building may seem to be essential for the new use, however, the new additions should be avoided, if possible, and considered only after it has been determined that their needs cannot be met by altering secondary or non-character defining interior spaces. If an exterior addition is the only viable alternative, it should be designed and constructed to be clearly differentiated from the historic building so that the character defining features are not radically changed, obscured, damaged or destroyed.
(3) The site and landscape plan shall be sensitive to the individual building, its occupants and their needs, and shall be visually compatible with the buildings and environment with which it is visually related, including, but not limited to, site orientation, setbacks, transitional moving elements and vegetative or other screening.
(4) New signs shall be compatible with and designed to compliment the historic character of the buildings and environment to which they are visually related.
(5) New construction on an archaeologically significant site shall ensure that artifacts are not destroyed and that they are accessible.
(b) Alterations to existing buildings.
(1) The criteria set forth in subsection (a) above shall be considered insofar as applicable to the historic and/or cultural characteristics of the buildings, structures or sites visually related to it.
(2) Alterations shall not degrade the architectural quality or historic character of the building, structure or site, but shall, to the extent possible, maintain or restore the historic design and conditions. To the extent possible, significant historical materials and features shall be retained and repaired.
a. If beyond repair, the materials and features should be replaced in-kind, if possible. In the event that it is not possible or economically feasible to replace deteriorated material or features in-kind, replacement shall duplicate the appearance of the original material, as closely as possible, on site-specific historical documentation or physical evidence.
b. Conjectural design of missing features shall be discouraged.
(3) New signs on existing buildings shall be consistent with the historic and/or cultural character of the building and the environment in which it is located. New signage should be designed, scaled and placed in the same manner as historic and/or cultural signage on the building.
(c) Demolition.
(1) Preservation of the historic, cultural, scenic or architectural significance of the building structures or site shall be considered.
(2) The difficulty or the impossibility of reproducing such a building or structure because of its design, texture, material, detail or unique location shall be considered.
(3) The future utilization of the historical, archeological or cultural site, including any replacement buildings, structures or landscape shall be considered.
(4) Whether the building, structure or archeological site are the last remaining examples of its kind in the neighborhood, the city, the county or the region shall be considered.
(5) The reasonable economic return on the building shall be considered.
(6) Upon determination by City Council that demolition or removal of a building or structure or disturbance of archeological artifacts is justified, relocation of the building, structure or archeological artifacts as a mitigating action should be considered.
(7) Upon determination by City Council that relocation of the building or structure is impractical, an archival recording, including photographic documentation, shall be made.
(d) Reconstruction. The reconstruction of a building or structure damaged by fire, storm or other act of God shall be reviewed by City Council according to the criteria in subsection (b) above. Totally or substantially new construction, regardless of reason, shall be reviewed according to the criteria set forth in subsection (a) above.
(e) Relocation.
(1) The historic and/or cultural character and aesthetic interest the building or structure contributes to its present location shall be considered.
(2) The future utilization of the site and the effect on the character of the surrounding district shall be considered.
(3) The ability to move the building or structure without significant damage to the building or structure shall be considered.
(4) The compatibility of the proposed relocation area with the historical, cultural and architectural character of the building or structure shall be considered.
(Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 34-00, 5-8-2000) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990)(Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997; Ord. 34-00, 5-8-2000) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990) (Ord. 115-90, 12-3-1990; Ord. 45-97, 8-11-1997; Ord. 34-00, § 1, 5-8-2000)