1.4.302: CIVIL ACTIONS:
A. Claims Arising Under State Law:
1. Whenever a claim is made against any City employee for injury or death which lies in tort or could lie in tort regardless of whether that may be the type of action chosen by the claimant, the City shall be liable for the costs of the defense of the employee, whether defense is assumed by the City or by other counsel, in the discretion of the City so long as the claim against the City employee arose out of injuries sustained from an act or omission of the employee which occurred, or is alleged in the complaint to have occurred, during the performance of the employee's duties and within the scope of employment, except where the act or omission is wilful and wanton. If it is determined at the trial that the injuries did not arise out of an act or omission during the performance of the employee's duties and within the scope of employment or that the act or omission was wilful and wanton, it shall be the responsibility of the employee to reimburse the City for reasonable costs incurred by it in the defense of the employee.
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection A1 of this section, the City shall not be responsible for providing a defense to a City employee where the City is not made a party defendant in the action and the City is not notified of the existence of the action in writing by the plaintiff or the employee within fifteen (15) days after service upon the employee of the summons and complaint. Further, the provisions of subsection A1 of this section shall not apply where a City employee wilfully and knowingly fails to notify the supervisor of the incident or occurrence which led to the claim within a reasonable time after the incident or occurrence.
3. Subject to the requirements of subsection A2 of this section, in the event the City elects not to assume the defense of the employee, the City nevertheless shall be liable to the employee for reasonable attorney fees and costs in prosecuting the employee's own defense unless the court determines that the injuries did not arise out of the employee's act or omission during the performance of duties and within the scope of employment, or that the employee's act or omission was wilful and wanton.
4. The City shall be liable for the payment of all judgments and settlement of claims against any of its employees where the claim against the employee arises out of injuries sustained from the employee's act or omission of the employee occurring during the performance of duties and within the scope of employment, except where the act or omission is wilful or wanton so long as the employee does not compromise or settle the claim without the consent of the City.
5. Notwithstanding anything contained in this section to the contrary, the City shall not be liable for the payment of any exemplary damages on behalf of any City employee without the prior consent of the City Council.
B. Claims Arising Under Federal Law:
1. To the extent that the doctrine of respondeat superior is applicable to any claim against a City employee arising under Federal law, the provisions set forth in subsection A of this section shall be applicable to the responsibilities of the City and the City employee with respect to the allocation of costs of defense and the payment of judgments and settlements on behalf of the employee.
2. In the event that the claim arising under Federal law against the City employee does not involve the doctrine of respondeat superior, then the City shall be responsible for providing a defense to the employee and to pay all judgments and settlements on behalf of the employee unless the court determines that the employee violated a Federally protected right and the employee was not entitled to immunity or did not act in good faith with respect to the act or omission which gave rise to the claim under Federal law.
3. In its discretion, the City may appoint separate counsel to represent the City employee, and shall be entitled to a reimbursement of all costs of defense incurred by the City on behalf of the employee if it is determined by the court that the acts or omissions of the employee which gave rise to the claim under Federal law were in violation of a Federally protected right and the employee was not entitled to immunity or did not act in good faith. This shall not require the City, in any case, to be responsible for exemplary damages awarded against a public employee for claims arising out of Federal law.
C. Civil Action Investigation Committee: To assist the City Council in making such findings and determinations, a committee consisting of the City Attorney, the Risk Manager, and the head of the affected employee's department, division, office, enterprise or agency for the City (or the Mayor, Utilities Chief Executive Officer or MHS Enterprise Chief Executive Officer if the employee charged is a department, division, office or agency Director or Manager) shall cause an investigation to be made of any civil action, and make a recommendation to the City Council whether the above criteria for paying the costs of defending the employee or the cost of payment of any judgment or settlement are required pursuant to the requirements of this section. In the interest of clarity, "MHS Enterprise" does not refer to any current or future operator of leased facilities under the Memorial Health System Affiliation or encompass such operator's employees. (Ord. 11-18; Ord. 15-62; Ord. 18-41)