Additional enforcement provisions.
Memphis Code of Ordinances § 13-24-84
in effectSec. 13-24-84. - Additional enforcement provisions.
A. Other enforcement actions. In addition to the enforcement remedies and responses otherwise identified in sections 13-24-70 through 13-24-83 of this chapter, noncompliance by a user may subject a user to enforcement response(s) including, but not limited to, a phone call, e-mail, notice of violation, increased monitoring, consent order or agreement, show cause request, case referral to Federal or state government, or such other remedy as the control authority deems appropriate. These enforcement responses include:
1. Notice of violation: The control authority may issue a notice of violation to a user when the control authority determines that a user violated, or continues to violate, any provision of this chapter, an SIU discharge permit, other user permit, enforcement order issued hereunder, or any pretreatment standard or pretreatment requirement. The notice of violation may request that the user promptly respond to the control authority and to identify, among other things, an explanation of the cause(s) of the violation and a plan for the satisfactory correction and prevention of future violations. Submission of the response by a user does not relieve the user of liability for any violations occurring before or after receipt of the notice of violation. Nothing in this section shall limit the authority of the control authority to take any action, including emergency actions or any other enforcement action, whether or not a notice of violation has been issued.
2. Increased monitoring: The control authority, in response to user violation(s), may require the user to increase the sampling and monitoring of its discharge or the control authority may undertake increased sampling and monitoring of the user's discharge. If increased monitoring is undertaken by the authority, the costs associated with such increased sampling and monitoring may be charged to the user.
The increase in a user's sampling and monitoring activities in response to violation(s) may be imposed upon the industrial user by the control authority issuing a modification to the user's SIU discharge permit or other user permit, issuing an administrative order, or by issuing any other appropriate mechanism. An option the control authority, subject to its discretion, may include in an SIU discharge permit or other user permit is a permit condition which automatically provides for increased sampling upon user noncompliance.
3. Consent order or consent agreement: The control authority may enter into a consent order or consent agreement when the control authority determines that a user violated, or continues to violate, any provision of this chapter, a SIU discharge permit, other user permit or enforcement order issued hereunder, or any pretreatment standard or pretreatment requirement. A consent order or consent agreement may provide for monetary penalties for past violation(s), stipulated monetary penalties for future violation(s), an enforceable compliance schedule setting forth specific action(s) to be taken by the user to correct noncompliance within a specified time period, and/or such other conditions as the control authority deems appropriate.
Failure of a user to comply with any condition or requirement set forth in a consent order or consent agreement is a violation of this chapter and each day of a violation is independently enforceable. A consent order and consent agreement have the full force of law and are enforceable in a court of law. A consent order is subject to judicial approval as a precondition to its effectiveness whereas a consent agreement is not subject to such judicial approval prior to its adoption.
4. Show cause request: The control authority may issue a show cause request to a user when the control authority determines that a user violated, or continues to violate, any provision of this chapter, a SIU discharge permit, other user permit, enforcement order issued hereunder, or any pretreatment standard or pretreatment requirement. A show cause request may provide for the user to appear before the control authority (at a show cause meeting) and show cause as to why a proposed or subsequent enforcement action should not be taken. Nothing in this section shall limit the authority of the control authority to take any action, including emergency actions or any other enforcement action, whether or not a show cause request has been issued or a show cause meeting has been held.
5. Referral to State or Federal government: The control authority may refer a matter to a Federal and/or state government for enforcement by such governmental entity when the control authority determines that a user violated, or continues to violate, any provision of this chapter, an SIU discharge permit, or enforcement order issued hereunder, or any pretreatment standard or pretreatment requirement. The control authority may assist the Federal and/or state government in a Federal or state-initiated enforcement action against a user.
B. City enforcement options not limited. Nothing in this chapter, the control authority's enforcement response plan, or any other provision of Memphis' approved pretreatment program shall be intended to limit the enforcement discretion of the control authority as otherwise provided for by law.
C. User liability for causing city violations. A user shall be liable for any penalty imposed upon the city (whether the penalty is a result of a judicial or administrative trial or hearing or the settlement of a judicial or administrative penalty action) where the city's violation was caused by the user, either alone or in conjunction with the discharge(s) from other source(s). Where the user has violated a local limit under section 13-24-44(C) and a violation of the NPDES permit applicable to the city's POTW subsequently occurred for the same pollutant or associated pollutant(s), a rebuttable presumption is deemed to exist that the permittee caused the violation of the NPDES permit. The user shall have the burden of proof to demonstrate that its discharge did not cause, in whole or part, the city to violate its NPDES permit limitation.
D. Exhaustion of administrative remedies and appeals. Any issue that was decided by the hearing authority in a prior hearing or could have been decided by the hearing authority had the permittee or defendant, as applicable, appealed the matter, shall be binding upon such permittee or defendant in subsequent hearing(s) unless there is a change in law (e.g., a court overturned the hearing authority's decision or the underlying ordinance standard has been amended) or a significant change in the underlying facts.
E. Need to halt or reduce activity not a defense. It shall not be a defense in an enforcement action that it would have been necessary to halt or reduce the permitted activity in order to maintain compliance with the conditions of this permit. See section 13-24-46(E), requiring the reduction in production as necessary to achieve compliance.
F. Duty to mitigate. The user shall take all reasonable steps to minimize or prevent any discharge which has a reasonable likelihood of adversely affecting human health or the environment or any action which has the reasonable likelihood of obstructing flow in the sewer collection system.
(Ord. No. 5793, §§ 3, 5, 8-17-2021)
Source: City of Memphis, Code of Ordinances and Charter and Related Laws (Municode Library, library.municode.com)URL: https://library.municode.com/tn/memphis/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=TIT13PUSE_CH13-24PR_ART4REEN_S13-24-84ADENPRFetched: 10/28/2026
