Process for determination of responsibility prequalification.
Columbus City Codes § 329.21
in effect329.21 - Process for determination of responsibility prequalification.
The requirements of this section apply to all construction service contracts, estimated to exceed five-hundred thousand dollars ($500,000), to be awarded and approved under Section 329.23(A).
A city agency may enter into contracts on behalf of the city for construction services so long as it is in compliance with the provisions of this section. The provisions of this section are as follows:
(a) The finance and management director or designee must propose and shall apply a process for responsibility prequalification. The director or designee shall utilize the aforementioned process to deem an applicant prequalified not responsible, prequalified provisionally responsible, or prequalified responsible, whichever is applicable. Such process shall use a quantified point system which does all of the following:
(1) Allocates specific maximum and minimum points for each responsibility factor listed herein, provided that one (1) or more factors may be used to screen applicants for the purpose of summarily deeming an applicant prequalified not responsible;
(2) Establishes criteria for uniformly assigning points based on an objective evaluation of the application for each responsibility factor, such that similarly situated applicants are assigned the same point value for the same factor;
(3) Conducts an objective evaluation of the information provided in the application and any supporting evidence that has been received by the city or adduced as a result of an investigation by the city;
(4) Based on the aforementioned objective evaluation and based on the aforementioned criteria, assigns points to each responsibility factor considered in the application;
(5) Provides a score for the application by totaling the points assigned to each responsibility factor; and
(6) Establishes the minimum and maximum score ranges by which an applicant shall be deemed prequalified not responsible, prequalified provisionally responsible, or prequalified responsible based on the applicant's score.
(b) The finance and management director or designee shall prescribe the form of the bi-annual (every other year) responsibility prequalification application and may prescribe a standardized questionnaire for objectively evaluating such application.
(c) The finance and management director or designee shall make a determination regarding a responsibility prequalification application pursuant to this section and shall notify applicants of the determination in writing. The notification must state the reasons for the determination and inform the applicant of any available administrative review or appeal.
(d) An applicant may appeal to the finance and management director or designee, in writing, the determination regarding the applicant's responsibility prequalification. After reasonable notice to the business entity involved and reasonable opportunity for that business entity to be heard, the finance and management director or designee shall make a determination regarding the appeal. The director of finance and management or designee shall issue a written decision and shall send a copy of the decision to the business entity involved. The decision shall state the reasons for the action taken. The decision of the finance and management director shall be final absent an appeal pursuant to this section.
(e) After reasonable notice to the business entity involved and reasonable opportunity for that business entity to be heard, the finance and management director or designee may, for good cause shown and in consultation with the city attorney, revoke any entity's prequalification as responsible or provisionally responsible. Such revocation may not exceed three (3) years. The director of finance and management or designee shall issue a written decision and shall send a copy of the decision to the business entity involved. The decision shall state the reasons for the action taken. The decision of the finance and management director shall be final absent an appeal pursuant to this section.
(f) (1)
Within ten days, an individual or entity may appeal, in writing on a form determined by the director, a determination of prequalification denied by the director of finance and management under division (d) or a determination of revocation exercised by the director of finance and management under division (e) to an independent hearing officer appointed by the finance and management director. A failure by an individual or entity to exercise this right to appeal shall constitute a waiver of such right.
(2) Notification of the opportunity to be heard by the hearing officer shall be given at least ten (10) days prior to the hearing.
(3) The independent hearing officer shall determine by a preponderance of the evidence whether there are sufficient grounds to uphold the determination of the director and the length of time of the revocation, if applicable. Based on the evidence presented by all parties, the independent hearing officer may increase, decrease, or accept the director of finance and management's recommendation regarding the length of revocation.
(4) The independent hearing officer decision on prequalification or revocation shall be in writing.
(5) The failure of an individual or entity to appear at a prequalification or revocation hearing after notice may constitute a waiver of that person's right to contest the director's decision on prequalification or revocation. If the independent hearing officer determines that the person has waived the right to contest the director's decision under this division, the director of finance and management's decision shall become final.
(g) All potential bidders and all licensed construction trade subcontractors seeking to perform any portion of work on city construction service work must submit to the finance and management director, or designee, a full and complete application for responsibility prequalification on a bi-annual basis (every other year), pursuant to this section. Entities currently prequalified responsible may sign an affidavit in the intervening years stating there has been no material changes to their previous application. Any material changes will require the submission of a new, full and complete application. The director of finance and management or designee may promulgate a renewal application for business entities currently prequalified responsible, which shall satisfy the requirements of this section.
(h) Only potential bidders prequalified responsible or prequalified provisionally responsible by bid opening may be awarded a contract for city construction service work. Only licensed construction trade subcontractors prequalified responsible or prequalified provisionally responsible by bid opening may subcontract or perform on city construction service work. No business entity prequalified not responsible may receive or perform city construction service work.
(i) A potential bidder or licensed construction trade subcontractor that is prequalified responsible may retain that status for twenty-four (24) consecutive months immediately following the date of that status determination.
(j) A potential bidder or licensed construction trade subcontractor that is prequalified provisionally responsible may retain that status for twenty-four (24) consecutive months following the date of that status determination.
(k) If a potential bidder or licensed construction trade subcontractor is deemed provisionally responsible and such bidder or subcontractor is not prequalified responsible within twenty-four (24) consecutive months following the date of the original status determination, they may not receive new city construction work or perform any portion of work on any new construction service project until they apply for responsibility prequalification as outlined in Section 329.21 and are determined to be prequalified responsible by the finance and management director or designee. The provisions of this division shall not affect eligibility to continue a current contract or subcontract for city construction work.
(l) If a potential bidder or licensed construction trade subcontractor is deemed not responsible and such bidder or subcontractor is not prequalified responsible within twelve (12) consecutive months following the date of the original status determination, they may not receive new city construction work or perform any portion of work on any new construction service project until they apply for responsibility prequalification as outlined in Section 329.21 and are determined to be prequalified responsible by the finance and management director or designee. The provisions of this division shall not affect eligibility to continue a current contract or subcontract for city construction work.
(m) The finance and management director or designee must promulgate rules regarding the following, at a minimum:
(1) The number of times a business entity may apply for responsibility prequalification in a set period of time;
(2) The length of time a business entity must wait prior to reapplying for responsibility prequalification after receiving a status determination;
(3) The length of time a business entity deemed provisionally responsible must wait to reapply for responsibility prequalification if such entity fails to be prequalified responsible within twenty-four (24) consecutive months following the date of the original status determination;
(4) The length of time a business entity deemed not responsible must wait to reapply for responsibility prequalification if such entity fails to be prequalified responsible within twelve (12) consecutive months following the date of the original status determination; and
(5) If a renewal application has been promulgated by the director or designee, the number of consecutive renewal applications that may be filed before a business entity must submit a full application for responsibility prequalification.
(n) The Director shall provide to Council a bi-annual report, no later than September 30th of every other calendar year, beginning in 2023, reviewing the Construction Prequalification requirements to ensure the policy is meeting city and community goals.
(Ord. No. 3062-2014, § 3, 12-15-2014; Ord. No. 2074-2021, § 2, 7-26-2021; Ord. No. 1823-2022, § 1, 7-11-2022; Ord. No. 2027-2022, § 1, 7-18-2022)
Source: City of Columbus, City Codes and City Charter (Municode Library, library.municode.com)URL: https://library.municode.com/oh/columbus/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=TIT3FITACO_CH329PRGOSEALPR_329.21PRDEREPRFetched: 10/27/2026
