4.19.060 - Grandfathered pension benefits.
A. Grandfathered benefits—General. The provisions of this section apply only to grandfathered participants. The amount of retirement income benefits accrued under this section is based on all service and compensation, including years of service rendered and compensation paid before the effective date, but is offset by benefits payable under the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis, as provided in Subsection G of this section, so that the benefit accrued under this plan is earned only because of years of service after the effective date, although vesting, eligibility for retirement and the rate of accrual for benefits attributable to years of service after the effective date is based on total years of service.
B. Reserved.
C. Grandfathered normal retirement benefit. Subject to the conditions and limitations of the Plan, a grandfathered participant who incurs a termination of employment on or after his normal retirement age of fifty-five (55) years and after completing at least twenty (20) years of service will be entitled to a monthly retirement income payable to the participant for his lifetime commencing at his normal retirement date in an amount equal to two (2) percent of the participant's average final compensation for each year of service up to twenty-five (25) years, and five (5) percent of the participant's average final compensation for each year of service over twenty-five (25) years, up to a maximum of seventy-five (75) percent of average final compensation. The monthly amount of the retirement income of such a participant shall not be increased actuarially to reflect an annuity starting date deferred beyond the normal retirement age of the participant.
Solely for purposes of computing such grandfathered benefit, sick leave accumulated under the FRS shall be credited as years of service and added to no more than a total of thirty (30) years of service for purposes of vesting and to allow such a participant to receive a monthly retirement income benefit in excess of seventy-five (75) percent of average final compensation. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, sick leave of a participant who is participating in DROP shall be subject to the provisions of Subsection E of this section.
A grandfathered participant who receives such a retirement income benefit shall receive a refund of his contributions to this plan, without interest; provided that contributions to the plan made on and after the effective date by a participant who had fewer than twenty (20) full years of service as of the effective date are not refundable. All refundable contributions are payable at the time of his pension commencement date.
D. Early retirement benefit. A grandfathered participant who incurs a termination of employment after completing twenty (20) years of service, but before completing thirty (30) years of service and before attaining his normal retirement age of fifty-five (55) years, shall be entitled to a monthly retirement income payable to the participant for his lifetime commencing on the first day of the month after he attains fifty-five (55) years of age, calculated as for normal retirement in accordance with the preceding subsection, based on his average final compensation and his years of service as of his termination of employment. In lieu of a deferred retirement income commencing at age fifty-five (55), such a participant may elect to receive his retirement income beginning on his termination of employment; or on the first day of any month thereafter prior to age fifty-five (55). The monthly amount otherwise payable at age fifty-five (55) that is attributable to years of service after the effective date shall be actuarially reduced from age fifty-five (55) to the pension commencement date in accordance with Section 4.19.020.B for a participant with fewer than twenty (20) full years of service as of the effective date. The monthly amount otherwise payable at age fifty-five (55) to a participant with more than twenty (20) full years of service as of the effective date shall be unreduced.
Solely for purposes of computing such grandfathered benefit, sick leave accumulated under the FRS shall be credited as years of service and added to no more than a total of thirty (30) years of service for purposes of vesting and to allow such a participant to receive a monthly retirement income benefit in excess of seventy-five (75) percent of average final compensation. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, sick leave of a participant who is participating in DROP shall be subject to the provisions of Subsection E of this section.
A grandfathered participant who receives such a retirement income benefit shall receive a refund of his contributions to this Plan, without interest; provided that contributions to the Plan made on and after the effective date by a participant with fewer than twenty (20) years of service as of the effective date are not refundable. All refundable contributions are payable at the time of his pension commencement date.
For example, a participant with ten (10) years of service on the effective date, who retires ten (10) years after the effective date, at age fifty (50) with a total of twenty (20) years of service, with annualized average final compensation of $80,000.00 for the last two (2) years before retirement, would be entitled to a deferred pension benefit of thirty-two thousand dollars ($32,000.00) (forty (40) percent of eighty thousand dollars ($80,000.00)) per year beginning at age fifty-five (55), or an immediate pension beginning at age fifty (50) of twenty-six thousand two hundred seventy-two dollars ($26,272.00). (The sixteen thousand dollars ($16,000.00) attributable to the ten (10) years of service before the effective date is unreduced; the sixteen thousand dollars ($16,000.00) attributable to the ten (10) years of service after the effective date is actuarially reduced from sixteen thousand dollars ($16,000.00) to ten thousand two hundred seventy-two dollars ($10,272.00).) Such amount is subject to the offset for the prior plan benefit as provided in Subsection G of this section.
A grandfathered participant who incurs a termination of employment before completing twenty (20) years of service shall receive a refund of his accumulated contributions with interest in lieu of any pension benefit.
E. DROP. Grandfathered participants who have completed at least twenty (20) years of service may elect to continue active employment and defer receipt of the retirement benefit for a period not to exceed five (5) years. Any grandfathered participant who has at least twenty (20) years of service may elect in writing before retirement to participate in the deferred retirement option program ("DROP"). A grandfathered participant electing to participate in the DROP program shall continue in active employment and shall not receive any direct retirement benefit payments during the time of participation. Upon the start of participation in the DROP program, the grandfathered participant shall make contributions at the rate of one (1) percent of compensation, instead of the contribution rate required by Section 4.19.030.B. During the period of participation in the DROP program, the amount that the grandfathered participant would have received as a monthly retirement income benefit (normal retirement benefit under Subsection C or reduced early retirement benefit under Subsection D, whichever is applicable) shall accumulate for the grandfathered participant until the grandfathered participant retires, unless the grandfathered participant has completed thirty (30) years of service, in which case he will receive a normal retirement benefit under Subsection C regardless of age. Years of service earned during the period of participation in the DROP program shall not be credited and shall not be counted in determination of any service-based retirement benefit.
A grandfathered participant who elects to stop participation in the DROP program shall make contributions at the rate of eight (8) percent of the compensation of each participant with at least twenty (20) full years of service as of the effective date, and nine (9) percent of the compensation of each participant with fewer than twenty (20) full years of service as of the effective date. Service rendered after restoration of the grandfathered participant to non-DROP participation status shall be counted as years of service. No grandfathered participant ending participation in the DROP program and returning to non-DROP participation status shall make any withdrawal from his or her DROP accumulation until after termination of employment. If after return to non-DROP participation status, a grandfathered participant retires, the grandfathered participant's retirement benefit shall be computed on the combination of the grandfathered participant's pre-DROP retirement benefit (based on average final compensation at the beginning of the DROP period and any applicable reduction for commencement before age fifty-five (55)) plus an additional benefit earned by the grandfathered participant after returning to non-DROP participation status. Post-DROP years of service shall be the only years used in computing the additional benefit; however, total years of service shall be used to determine the appropriate accrual level of additional benefit, two percent or five percent, for each year of post-DROP service. Upon retirement the grandfathered participant shall receive retirement income benefits plus the amount of his or her DROP accumulation. The grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation shall be payable, at the grandfathered participant's option, either as a lump sum payment or as a series of quarterly payments of reasonably equal amounts using the declining balance method over a period of fewer than ten years as selected by the grandfathered participant, subject to the minimum distribution rules of Section 4.19.100.B.
If a grandfathered participant dies before termination of employment while participating in the DROP program, his or her DROP accumulation shall be payable to the grandfathered participant's designated beneficiary under either of the following options:
1. A lump sum payment equal to the grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation shall be paid to the grandfathered participant's beneficiary or the grandfathered participant's estate. The death benefits for the beneficiary under the provisions of Section 4.19.080 shall be based on the grandfathered participant's compensation and years of service before the grandfathered participant's participation in the DROP program; or
2. The beneficiary may waive any claim to the grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation, in which case any death benefits payable to the beneficiary under the provisions of Section 4.19.080 shall be calculated as if the grandfathered participant had continued as an employee and had not participated in the DROP program. Any DROP accumulation which has been waived as provided in this paragraph shall become funds of the plan.
If a grandfathered participant who has elected to participate in the DROP program subsequently applies for and receives benefits for a disability benefit under the provisions of Section 4.19.070, the grandfathered participant shall forfeit all rights, claims or interest in his DROP accumulation and the grandfathered participant's benefits shall be calculated as if the grandfathered participant had continued in employment and had not elected to participate in the DROP program. Any DROP accumulation which has been forfeited as provided in this plan shall become funds of the plan.
The balance of a grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation shall be credited with interest for each plan year under one (1) of the following two options, as elected by the grandfathered participant upon entering DROP: (1) the rate of return of the trust fund's investment portfolio, as certified annually by the actuary in the yearly evaluation report, for the preceding plan year, as approved by the trustees, subject to a minimum rate of return of zero (0) percent; or (2) the rate of return equal to the yield on the ten-year treasury bond as of the end of the preceding plan year, subject to a minimum rate of return of zero (0) percent.
Interest shall be credited annually to the grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation beginning with the start of the second plan year of participation, based on the balance at the beginning of the plan year. If a withdrawal occurs during a plan year, interest will be determined pro rata for each partial plan year before and after the withdrawal.
No participant may elect to participate in the DROP program more than once.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Chapter, a grandfathered participant who is participating in the DROP program may elect upon termination of employment to have added to his or her DROP accumulation a dollar amount equal to the number of his sick leave hours accumulated under the FRS multiplied by his or her hourly rate of pay at the time of termination of employment, net of the amount, if any, required to be withheld as taxes by the applicable governmental authorities; or to add one-half of such dollar amount in the grandfathered participant's DROP accumulation, to add one-quarter of such dollar amount to the aggregate total of the grandfathered participant's monthly compensation for the period used in calculating the grandfathered participant's average final compensation, and to have the remaining one-fourth of such sick leave remain as time and added to the grandfathered participant's years of service before the effective date. A grandfathered participant may make such an election to have sick leave hours converted to a combination of DROP accumulation, years of service and average final compensation only if the participant made a comparable election under The Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis; and a grandfathered participant who made such an election under The Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis shall be deemed to have made such an election under this Plan; so that the DROP benefit payable from this Plan shall be paid in the same form as the benefit payable under The Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis.
F. Cost of living increases. The grandfathered benefit payable in accordance with Subsections C, D and E of this section shall be increased annually, as approved by the Board of Trustees beginning with the first increase in the October following retirement of the participant and subsequent increases in each October thereafter, at the rates designated as follows:
1. One and one-half (1.5) percent per year, compounded each year, up to age sixty (60) for those retiring with at least twenty (20) years of service but less than twenty-five (25) years of service,
2. Two and one-fourth (2.25) percent per year, compounded each year, up to age sixty (60) for those retiring with at least twenty-five (25) years of service but less than thirty (30) years of service,
3. Three (3) percent per year, compounded each year, up to age sixty (60) for those retiring with thirty (30) or more years of service,
4. After age sixty (60), five (5) percent per year for five (5) years or until a total maximum increase of twenty-five (25) percent is reached.
Each increase, however, is subject to a determination by the Board of Trustees that the consumer price index shows an increase of not less than the approved rate during the preceding twelve-month period as designated by the Board of Trustees for the purpose of promoting consistency with the Consumer Price Index used by the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis. If the increase is in excess of the approved rate for any year, the excess shall be accumulated as to any retired participant and increases granted in subsequent years subject to the maximum allowed for each full year from October following his retirement but not to exceed a total increase of twenty-five (25) percent. If the Board of Trustees determines that the index has decreased for any year, the benefits of any retired participant that have been increased shall be decreased but not below his initial benefit. No annual increase shall be made of less than one (1) percent and no decrease of less than three (3) percent except that any decrease shall be limited by the initial benefit.
In addition to the above, grandfathered participants may share in ad hoc COLAs, if any, to which they would be entitled in accordance with the terms and conditions of the prior plan as if such terms and conditions were included in this plan.
G. Prior plan benefit offset—No duplication rule. Subsections 4.19.050.F and G shall apply to all benefits, including grandfathered benefits. Notwithstanding anything in this plan to the contrary, the retirement income benefit payable under this plan shall be offset by the amount of retirement income payable under the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis (and any other defined benefit plan maintained by the City of St. Louis that is qualified under Section 401 of the Code) to the extent that the benefit under such other plan or plans is based on years of service used as the multiplier (times a percent of compensation) for purposes of determining the retirement income benefit under this plan, so that the benefit accrued under this plan is earned only because of years of service after the effective date, although vesting, eligibility for retirement and the rate of accrual for benefits attributable to years of service after the effective date is based on total years of service. The retirement income benefit offset shall be computed as if the participant had received his retirement income under the offset plan in the form of a single life annuity commencing on the day benefits commence to be paid under this plan.
The benefit of a participant who enters DROP on or after February 1, 2013 shall be determined under this plan, based on all service, including prior plan service, but the benefit of such a participant shall be offset by the benefit payable under The Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis, so that the benefit accrued under this plan is earned only because of years of service after the effective date. No member has accrued any sick leave benefits under this plan. The benefit under this plan of a grandfathered participant who elects to have sick leave hours converted shall be adjusted so that the aggregated total of each of such benefits payable by both this plan and the offset plan mirrors but does not exceed the amount of such benefits to which the participant would have received under this plan if all such service and compensation had been taken into account only by this plan.
Notwithstanding anything in this plan to the contrary, there shall be no duplication of any benefit under this plan of a benefit payable from The Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis that is attributable to years of service for which a participant is entitled to an accrued benefit under the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis, no duplication of any death or disability benefit paid under the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis, and no duplication of any benefit under this plan attributable to accumulated sick pay, DROP, or any other factor credited under the Firemen's Retirement System of St. Louis.
(1994 C., § 4.19.060; Ord. No. 71807, §§ 2, 3, 3-13-2024; Ord. No. 70248, §§ 15—19, 3-22-2016; Ord. No. 69353, §§ 12—16, 12-28-2012; Ord. No. 69245, § 2, 7-29-2012.)