Sec. 29-212. - General health care and management requirements.
(a) Findings of fact. City council hereby makes the following findings of fact:
(1) The City of Charleston, carriage company operators, residents, and visitors to the City of cHarleston have sought to take a proactive approach to protect and ensure the health, safety and welfare of animals used in the tourism industry;
(2) A study was conducted to develop and recommend animal welfare policies to the tourism commission. In response to the study, the tourism commission formed the ad hoc committee on animal-drawn carriages which committee was comprised of representatives from the tourism commission, animal control, the carriage industry, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals ("SPCA"), and an independent veterinarian;
(3) The ad hoc committee on animal-drawn carriages has now reviewed and updated the previously recommended policies after much deliberation and with input from the general public, Carriage Operators of North America ("CONA"), and the veterinarian community; and
(4) The codification of the ad hoc committee on animal-drawn carriages recommended regulations is in the best interest of protecting the health, safety, and welfare of the animals used in the tourism industry and protects the health, safety, and welfare of motorists and pedestrians using the public right-of-ways along with the residents and tourists of the City of Charleston.
(b) Definitions. Except where the context clearly indicates otherwise, the following terms and phrases as used in this section shall have the following meanings:
(1) Animal shall mean any horse or mule used for touring purposes and operated under a franchise agreement as outlined in section 29-202.
(2) Contamination shall mean the introduction of unwholesome or undesirable elements, including but not limited to, bedding, mold, bugs, and rodent droppings.
(3) Equine sanitation flag shall mean the marker used to identify animal excreta and is generally recognized as a two and one-half-inch rubber ball cut in half with an eight-inch surveyor's flag attached.
(4) Farrier shall mean a specialist in horse care who addresses the hooves, feet and legs of the animal.
(5) Free choice shall mean that water shall be ready and in front of a horse for fifteen(15) minutes after a tour is conducted so that a horse is free to choose to drink or not to drink water.
(6) GPS unit shall mean a device supplied at the gate for the use of marking animal excreta.
(7) Halter shall mean a headcollar or other proper equine or livestock headgear that is used to safely lead or tie up an animal that fits behind the ears (behind the poll) and around the muzzle.
(8) Hitching shall mean the act of either attaching or detaching an animal to or from a carriage through the use of a harness secured to the animal.
(9) Inspection shall mean to permit the department of livability and tourism, the police department, or a city contracted veterinarian to enter upon the premises of any carriage company subject to this ordinance to make inspections and to examine and audit required records.
(10) Old and Historic District shall mean that portion of the city that is so designated from time to time on the official zoning map of the city.
(11) Out of service shall mean when the animal is unhitched from a carriage and out of its harness.
(12) Police department shall mean the chief of police or his or her designee.
(13) Rest shall mean the time when the animal is in service but not performing work as defined herein.
(14) Stable shall mean the barn where the animals are kept.
(15) Stall shall mean individual space within the barn where each animal is kept.
(16) Tie(s) shall mean a lead rope, crosstie, or other item used to connect the animal to either a handler or anchor point. Ties shall be strong to ensure the safe securing or handling of the animal and all hardware accompanying such ties shall also be strong enough for such safe handling. Ties and or their accompanying hardware shall be removed from usage if damaged and not able to safely secure the animal.
(17) Tour or touring shall mean the conducting of or the participation in sightseeing in the districts for hire or in exchange for a donation.
(18) Touring stock shall mean all animals used for touring pursuant to this section.
(19) Vintage carriage shall mean any carriage built before 1900.
(20) Work and working shall mean the act of pulling a carriage.
(c) Equipment.
(1) Every carriage used for touring purposes and operated under a franchise agreement as outlined in section 29-202 shall be equipped with the following:
a. Head lights or lanterns and tail lights or lanterns which are visible for a distance of (500) feet when the carriage is operated from a half hour after sunset to a half hour before sunrise, and at any other time when windshield wipers are in use as a result of rain, sleet, or snow, or when inclement weather or environmental factors severely reduce the ability to clearly discern persons and vehicles on the street or highway at a distance of five hundred feet ahead. High reflectivity markers on the front, back and sides of the carriage as well as on the harness of the carriage-animal shall also be required;
b. A slow moving vehicle emblem attached to the rear of the carriage;
c. A diapering apparatus that prevents the droppings of the animal used to pull the carriage from being deposited on the ground or the right-of-way;
d. A fifth wheel or cut under turning mechanism on the front axle with the exception of vintage carriages;
e. Reflective ankle cuffs or another reflective device approved by the tourism committee shall be used on at least two (2) of the animal's legs if one (1) animal is pulling a carriage, or if two (2) animals are pulling a carriage reflective ankle cuffs or another reflective device approved by the tourism committee shall be used on at least one (1) of the outside legs of each animal when the carriage is operated from a half (½) hour after sunset to a half (½) hour before sunrise, and at any other time when windshield wipers are in use as a result of rain, sleet, or snow, or when inclement weather or environmental factors severely reduce the ability to clearly discern persons and vehicles on the street or highway at a distance of five hundred (500) feet ahead;
f. A two-way electronic communication system; and
g. A minimum of two (2) equine sanitation flags to mark animal excreta droppings.
h. One (1) GPS unit to mark animal excreta.
(2) Carriages must be properly lubricated and the carriage wheels shall spin freely.
(3) Each carriage shall be maintained in a safe condition so as to not endanger any person or property.
(4) Each carriage shall be maintained in a clean and sanitary condition, free of liter and debris and at all times suitable for public transportation of passengers.
(5) No carriage shall be operated having more passengers than what is permitted by its certificate of appropriateness or having a combined weight of carriage, passengers, and drivers that is more than three (3) times the weight of the animal(s) pulling the vehicle.
(d) Carriage stands, client pick-up locations, staging areas, and barns.
(1) Carriages queuing in the medallion booth line shall move and circle the block during equine sanitation cleaning.
(2) Each carriage company shall ensure that their animals in the queue line at the medallion booth shall have a fresh water source every hour.
(3) Each carriage company shall post at their barns in a conspicuous place signage as required under applicable federal, state, and local laws, including but not limited to, the Equine Activity Liability Act (S.C. Code 47-9-730), along with providing brochures outlining the City's ordinances governing the general health and welfare of the animals used in the tourism industry of Charleston.
(e) Care and shelter of animals.
(1) No animal shall be used to draw a carriage unless the animal is in good health and the following standards are met:
a. The animal shall not have open sores, open wounds, diarrhea, nor shall the animal be lame or have any other ailments unless the department of livability and tourism as well as the individual company's stable has a current written statement by a veterinarian on file that the animal is fit for such work not withstanding such condition. Further, the written statement by the veterinarian must have a required expiration date;
b. The hooves of all animals while engaged in work on pavement, brick, concrete or other like hard surfaces shall have rubber or elastomer shoes, boots or pads to prevent slipping and shall be evenly trimmed and shod. However, steel shoes can be used upon introduction to the touring stock during an initial two-week trial period. Also, if a farrier determines that the horse's hooves will not accommodate the use of rubber pads, metal shoes can be used on the rear legs of the animal;
c. The animal shall be properly and appropriately groomed;
d. The animal shall have adequate flesh and muscle tone as determined by the Body Condition Scale of the Henneke Chart and shall average between 4 and 7;
e. The animal is kept in good working condition;
f. At introduction into the touring stock then bi-annually thereafter, the animal shall have had a physical inspection completed by and a certificate of serviceability for carriage work signed by a licensed equine veterinarian, with the results thereof provided to the City of Charleston Department of Livability and Tourism and made available for inspection on site. Additionally, written documentation from a certified scale verifying the weight of the animal shall he provided at introduction into the touring stock. Written documentation from a certified scale may be required on an as needed basis;
g. All animals upon reasonable notice by the department of livability and tourism or police department shall be made available for an annual physical inspection to be conducted by the department of livability and tourism or police department's veterinarian with the results thereof being maintained by the department of livability and tourism with a copy being provided to the carriage company operator;
h. At introduction into the touring stock then quarterly thereafter, the animal shall have been de-wormed; and
i. At introduction into the touring stock, the animal has been vaccinated under the direction of a veterinarian for appropriate diseases and risk factors of the area, as outlined on the certificate of serviceability.
(2) Free choice water shall be provided to each animal immediately after completing a tour for a minimum of fifteen (15) minutes.
(3) Animals shall be provided electrolyte supplements at each feeding.
(4) Animals shall have at least fifteen (15) minutes rest between back to back tours.
(5) In a twenty-four-hour period, animals shall not engage in Work more than eight (8) consecutive hours or ten hours with out a one and one-half (1½) hour break being disconnected from the carriage, in a twenty-four-hour period.
(6) Animals shall not engage in work more than six (6) days in a seven-day period.
(7) Animals shall not engage in work with equipment causing an impairment of vision, other than normal blinders.
(8) Animals shall not be driven at a speed faster than a slow trot.
(9) Animals shall not be subject to any cruel or harassing treatment or equipment.
(10) Animals shall not be sold or disposed of except in a humane manner in accordance with American Association of Equine Practitioners' guidelines.
(11) Animals shall be at least three and one-half (3½ years of age and shall not weigh less than nine hundred fifty (950) pounds in fit condition.
(f) Harnesses.
(1) Animals shall not engage in work with harnesses or bits that harm or are unsafe to the animal.
(2) Harnesses, bridles, bits and padding shall be properly fitted and kept in clean and good repair.
(3) Harnesses shall be kept free of makeshifts like wire, rope, and rusty chain.
(4) Collars shall be sized appropriately for each equine.
(5) Harnesses, collars, blinders, bits, and bridles should exhibit no frayed or torn parts or evidence or being taped or other such sub-standard repairs.
(6) Trace chains shall not put pressure on the collar and shoulders of the animal when it starts pulling the carriage resulting in a jolting start versus a smooth start with a snug collar already in place.
(7) Breeching shall fit so that it will not rub or hinder the hind leg movement of the animal.
(g) Weather conditions.
(1) Carriage company operators and drivers shall use caution when Working animals in adverse weather conditions such as high heat and humidity, snow, ice, heavy rain, and other slippery or reduced visibility situations.
(2) When the ambient temperature reaches or exceeds eighty-five (85) degrees Fahrenheit at any point during the carriage company's hours of operation, the carriage company operators shall implement a mandatory system of taking the rectal temperature of each working animal immediately after completing a tour. In the event an animal's temperature reaches one hundred three (103) degrees Fahrenheit or above, the animal's temperature shall be taken every fifteen (15) minutes until the animal's temperature falls below one hundred three (103) degrees Fahrenheit before the animal is allowed to return to work.
(3) When the rectal temperature of an animal reaches between 103—103.9 degrees Fahrenheit, the carriage company operator shall require the animal to be removed from service and be cooled down to a temperature of 101.5 degrees Fahrenheit before returning them to engage in Work.
(4) In the event that an animal's rectal temperature reaches 104 degrees Fahrenheit or above the animal shall be taken out of service for the day and cooled down.
(5) In the event an animal can not be cooled down to a rectal temperature of 101.5 degrees Fahrenheit within two (2) hours of the first 103 degree Fahrenheit or above rectal temperature recording, a veterinarian shall be immediately contacted to inspect the animal.
(6) At any time when an animal's rectal temperature reaches 105.0 or above, or if any animal shows signs of distress such as panting motions, thumping of the chest (synchronous diaphramic flutter), tying up, or stiffening of legs or back, muscle trembling, or colic, a veterinarian shall be immediately contacted to inspect the animal.
(7) When either the ambient temperature reaches ninety-five (95) degrees Fahrenheit or the Heat Index reaches one hundred ten (110) degrees Fahrenheit, as determined by the department of livability and tourism or the police department after having received four (4) consecutive ambient temperature and/or heat index readings, which readings were taken at least fifteen (15) minutes apart that demonstrate that the ambient temperature and/or heat index equals or is above the stated ambient temperature or heat index as provided herein, the carriage company operators shall discontinue working their animals and remove them from the streets until the temperature decreases below the above-stated temperatures as authorized by the department of livability and tourism or the police department. When such a determination is made, the authorized city employee of the department of livability and tourism or the police department making the determination shall contact the medallion gate and the carriage operators of such determination and require that all carriage operations shall be discontinued until such time as the department of livability and tourism or the police department authorizes the carriages to return to the streets. The department of livability and tourism or the police department shall monitor the temperature and heat index and authorize the carriage operations to begin operating on the streets again after it is determined that the temperature is below ninety-five (95) degrees Fahrenheit and/or the heat index is below one hundred ten (110) degrees Fahrenheit for a period of thirty (30) minutes from the time of the first reading. However, if the temperature and/or heat index rises above the prescribed numbers at any time during the first thirty (30) minutes, the process starts over until the ambient temperature remains below ninety-five (95) degrees Fahrenheit and/or the heat index remains below one hundred ten (110) degrees Fahrenheit for thirty (30) consecutive minutes. At that time the authorized city employee of the department of livability and tourism or the police department making the determination shall notify the medallion gate and the carriage operators to advise that the medallion gate and carriage operators shall be permitted to resume the operation of the medallion gate and the working of their animals for tours on the streets.
(8) The official thermometer used for determining the temperature and the heat index shall be located at 181 Church Street in the City and County of Charleston, South Carolina. In the event this thermometer is out of service, as determined by the department of livability and tourism or the police department, the back-up thermometer shall be the thermometer at the Dock Street Theater located at 135 Church Street in the City and County of Charleston, South Carolina, or as determined by the department of livability and tourism if the back-up thermometer is no longer available.
(h) Feeding.
(1) Animals shall receive an adequate amount of equine feed daily, which is free from contamination, sufficient in quantity, having nutritional value, and be provided frequently enough to meet normal daily requirements for the animal's condition, special needs, environmental factors and size of the animal so as to maintain a healthy flesh.
(2) Clean drinking water free from contamination shall be available to an out of service animal at all times.
(3) Out of service animals shall at all times have access to salt in a block or loose form.
(i) Stables and stalls.
(1) Stables shall be safe, well lighted, ventilated, and provide protection from the weather as described herein;
a. Stables and stalls shall be kept clean and in good repair and excreta shall be removed daily;
b. The floors of the stalls shall be graded and raked to keep their surface dry; each stall shall have rubber mats under the shavings or shavings with a minimum depth of four (4) inches;
c. Fans shall be used to increase ventilation when the ambient temperature reaches eighty (80) degrees Fahrenheit;
d. Sharp surfaces and any other hazards shall not be permitted in any stable or stall where they can come in contact with the animals;
e. Stables and stalls shall be kept free of leaks, including but not limited to, leaks form roofs or from plumbing;
f. Stalls sizes shall be no less than five (5) feet nine (9) inches by eleven (11) feet unless a carriage company undertakes any remodeling or refurbishing of any sorts to their stable that equals fifty (50) percent of the market value of the stable or moves their stable. In the event a carriage company does remodel or refurbish their stable as stated in the previous sentence then they must implement a minimum stall size of twelve (12) feet by twelve (12) feet for every stall;
g. The practice of tethering the animal in a stall is permitted so long as the animal can lie down without the risk of entanglement or injury;
h. Occupied stalls shall have a minimum of three (3) inches of bedding or have a specialized surface so as to keep animals clean, dry and free of concussion, abrasion or pressure points;
i. Interior and exterior areas of the stable shall be kept clean, properly drained and free of nuisances including, but not limited to, unreasonable and excessive odors and unreasonable accumulation of refuse and excreta;
j. There shall be no smoking at any time in stables; and
k. Unless otherwise directed by a veterinarian, animals shall be given a pasture turn-out time of a minimum of four (4) consecutive days to total fourteen (14) days within four (4) months;
(2) Stables shall be located within walking distance the medallion gate located at the corner of Church and North Market.
(3) All stables shall have a yearly inspection by the fire department. Fire extinguishers must be kept in obvious places in every stable as required by law and as recommended by the fire department.
(j) Recordkeeping.
(1) Feeding, shoeing, medication, and treatment logs, bi-annual inspection records, certificate of serviceability, quarterly de-worming records, rectal temperature logs, work schedules, disposal documentation, and such other records as requested by the director of livability and tourism or his/her designee and police department shall be maintained for a three-year period by each carriage company operator for every animal used in the touring stock.
(k) Inspections. In addition to the annual inspection provided for herein, animals, facilities and records shall be subject to random or unannounced inspections at the discretion of the director of livability and tourism or his/her designee, police department, and/or the city designated veterinarian. The inspector is permitted to take notes, pictures and video if they deem appropriate. These inspections shall be brief in order to not interfere with the work flow of the business. The inspector should be allowed to enter the premises no longer than fifteen (15) minutes after arrival at the facility during business hours.
(l) Hitching.
(1) All animals must be properly secured while being hitched or unhitched from any carriage or apparatus to ensure all animals remain under control during either process. A properly secured animal is one that is secured in any of the following manners:
a. Having at least one (1) tie when the tie is securing the animal to a physical barrier. A physical barrier is limited in this circumstance to mean only a wall, a horse trailer stationed in front of the animals so that the animal cannot walk through, or permanent fixture specifically designed for the safe securing of animals.
b. When no physical barrier is present, two (2) ties are required. These ties will be connecting the animal on the left and right side of the harness to a secured anchor point on each side, with a minimum of eight (8) feet between the two secured anchor points.
(2) Ties, in no situation, shall ever be attached to bridles or bits while being worn by the animal;
(3) All animals must wear halters during the hitching and unhitching processes. Halters shall also remain on underneath the bridle while harnessed.
(4) The animal must be completely unhitched before the bridle may be removed.
(m) Annual training certifications.
(1) Each animal-drawn carriage company shall implement a structured annual training program subject to the approval of the city for both its tour guides, and carriage operators to ensure proficiency when operating on the public right-of-way.
(2) Each animal-drawn carriage company shall implement a structured annual training program subject to the approval of the city for every employee who comes into contact with its animals in any capacity to have basic knowledge and training to include proper procedures and tacking methods to ensure proper fit and care of the animals and equipment.
(3) Each animal-drawn carriage company shall make available a report to the department of livability and tourism for inspection no less than once per year on the completion of annual or other mandated training of all drivers.
(Ord. No. 2007-90, § 1, 4-24-07; Ord. No. 2011-58, §§ 1—10, 8-16-11; Ord. No. 2011-59, § 1, 8-16-11; Ord. No. 2011-60, § 1, 8-16-11; Ord. No. 2015-164, §§ 17—19, 11-10-15; Ord. No. 2016-070, § 7, 5-24-16; Ord. No. 2017-034, § 2, 3-28-17; Ord. No. 2017-151, § 2, 12-11-17; Ord. No. 2019-026, §§ 4, 5, 4-9-19; Ord. No. 2019-099, § 1, 10-8-19; Ord. No. 2020-123, §§ 1, 2, 9-8-20; Ord. No. 2021-127, § 5, 9-14-21; Ord. No. 2022-110, §§ 1, 2, 8-16-22; Ord. No. 2023-064, § 12, 3-28-23)