Sec. 54-905. - Rules and procedures for vehicle impoundment hearings.
At all hearings and proceedings conducted under the provisions of this division, the following rules shall apply:
(a) The hearings shall be informal. The county court rules of civil and criminal procedure, the municipal rules of procedure and other judicial rules shall not apply.
(b) The hearings shall be brief. The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall control the presentation of testimony, exhibits, and argument to ensure that it is relevant and brief. Except in the most unusual circumstances, no hearing should exceed fifteen (15) minutes.
(c) The rules of evidence shall not apply. The vehicle impoundment hearing officer may admit whatever evidence the vehicle impoundment hearing officer determines to be relevant to the issues and reasonably trustworthy. All other evidence shall be excluded.
(d) Claimants and the city may be represented by legal counsel.
(e) The standard of proof shall be a preponderance of the evidence.
(f) The claimant shall have the burden of proving: (1) that jurisdiction exists; and (2) that he or she is the owner or presently entitled to possession of the vehicle, or in the event that the vehicle has already been redeemed, is the person who paid the charges to redeem the vehicle from impoundment. These issues shall be determined in the following sequence. First, jurisdiction shall be determined. Only if it is determined that jurisdiction exists will the hearing officer proceed further. Second, the hearing officer shall determine whether the claimant is the owner or presently entitled to possession of the vehicle, or in the event that the vehicle already has been redeemed, is the person who paid the charges to redeem the vehicle from impoundment. Only if it is determined that the claimant is the owner or presently entitled to possession, or is the person who paid the charges to redeem the vehicle from impoundment, will the vehicle impoundment hearing officer proceed further. Finally, the hearing officer shall determine whether probable cause for the impoundment existed at the time of the impoundment.
(g) The city shall have the burden of proving that there existed, at the time the vehicle was impounded, probable cause to impound the vehicle under any provision of the Denver Revised Municipal Code or the Colorado Revised Statutes.
(h) Ordinarily, the city will carry its burden of proof not by the presentation of witnesses, but by the presentation of sworn documents showing why the vehicle was impounded. These documents shall be accepted into evidence without further foundation or sponsorship by any witness. The city or the vehicle impound lot may transmit facsimile copies of documents to the vehicle impoundment hearing officer before the hearing. These copies shall be accepted into evidence in the same manner as originals. A sworn document stating the reason the vehicle was impounded shall constitute prima facie evidence that probable cause for a lawful impoundment existed at the time the vehicle was impounded if the stated reason for impoundment constitutes grounds for impoundment under any provision of the Denver Revised Municipal Code or the Colorado Revised Statutes.
(i) The city may elect to appear at the hearing solely through documents.
(j) Any claimant who wishes to cross-examine the officer or city employee who impounded the vehicle or was otherwise involved in the impoundment may subpoena the officer to the hearing by (1) setting a hearing; and (2) obtaining the name of the city officers or employees responsible for impoundment of the vehicle from the vehicle impoundment hearing officer; and (3) obtaining subpoenas from the vehicle impoundment hearing officer; and (4) serving the subpoenas along with witness fees and mileage on the officer or employee at least forty-eight (48) hours before the hearing in accordance with the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure and the Colorado Revised Statutes.
(k) The claimant and the city may present testimony and exhibits relevant to the issues.
(l) All testimony shall be taken under an oath administered by the vehicle impoundment hearing officer.
(m) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall keep a tape recorded record of the proceedings.
(n) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall issue a written decision containing findings of fact and law immediately after the hearing, and shall provide the claimant and the Denver Impound Lot with a copy of the decision. The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall retain the original of the decision as part of the file and the record.
(o) Claimants may submit briefs, summaries, or other writings if relevant to the issues.
(p) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall not entertain any motions. The issues shall be strictly limited to those specified in section 54-903.
(q) No hearing shall be set, scheduled or held unless the claimant does so within the time period specified in the notice of right to hearing mailed or hand delivered to him or her.
(r) Hearings shall be set by the claimant or his attorney in writing or by telephoning or personally appearing at the office of the vehicle impoundment hearing officer. Attorneys shall submit their written entry of appearance containing their name, address, telephone number, and Colorado Supreme Court Registration Number. No appearance by attorney shall be permitted until such an entry of appearance has been filed. No person may appear on behalf of or as the representative of any other person unless licensed to practice law within the State of Colorado and an entry of appearance is submitted.
(s) The claimant's failure to appear at the hearing, either in person or by attorney, constitutes a default and the vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall enter a decision for the city. The city's failure to appear at the hearing, either through its attorney, employee, or through documents shall constitute a default. The hearing officer may enter a default against the city and in favor of the claimant for the city's failure to appear, but only if the claimant appears and carries his burden of proving (1) that jurisdiction exists; and (2) that the claimant is the owner or presently entitled to possession of the vehicle or paid the charges for redemption of the vehicle. In the event that both the claimant and the city fail to appear, the hearing officer shall enter a default against the claimant.
(t) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer may question any witness including the claimant and may call the claimant and any other person present as a witness, unless that witness or the testimony elicited is privileged as provided by law.
(u) Claimants may examine any documents in the vehicle impoundment hearing officer's file at the time of the hearing including all documents sent to the hearing by the city. Claimants may also obtain the name of the officers or other city employees responsible for the impound in order to subpoena them. This is the only discovery permitted.
(v) In order to set a hearing, the claimant or his attorney must telephone or personally appear at the office of the vehicle impoundment hearing officer. If the impoundment involves a vehicle that has been booted, the hearing may be held immediately or set for a hearing within ten (10) calendar days. If the impoundment does not involve a booting, the hearing shall set within ten (10) calendar days of the setting. If the claimant wishes to obtain subpoenas, the claimant must set a hearing and request them at the time of the setting. No hearing shall be set more than ten (10) days after the setting.
(w) The claimant is solely responsible for personal service of subpoenas on the witnesses. The claimant is solely responsible for enforcement of the subpoena.
(x) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer, his or her staff, and city employees shall not mediate, plea-bargain, or negotiate any case.
(y) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall not obtain or accept any communication from any person, nor examine any document from any source, concerning the merits of the case until the hearing, except as may be necessary to set the matter for hearing, issue subpoenas, obtain documentation from the city, or to perform other administrative functions.
(z) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall not form or express any opinion as to the merits or outcome of the case until after the hearing has been completed.
(aa) A decision against any individual claimant is final and binding as to that claimant, but shall not bind other claimants to the same vehicle.
(bb) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall maintain a file on each such hearing consisting of at least all documents provided by the city or the vehicle impound lot, all documents submitted by the claimant, the vehicle impoundment hearing officer's decision, and a reference to the tape recording for the hearing.
(cc) The vehicle impoundment hearing officer shall have the right to control the hearing and the conduct of all persons who appear at the hearing. Any party who fails, neglects or refuses to comply with the hearing officer's orders, or who engages in any conduct which disrupts the conduct of any hearing or the administration of any act or duty authorized or required under this division shall have a default judgment entered against them.
(dd) Claimants and attorneys shall appear in person at the hearing and not by telephone or other electronic means.
(ee) In the event that the vehicle already has been redeemed, proof that a person paid the charges to redeem the vehicle shall be made by presenting the receipt from the Denver Impound Lot showing payment of the charges for that vehicle.
(ff) The presiding judge of the county court may promulgate supplementary rules and procedures for the conduct of hearings and administration of this division, but all such supplementary rules and procedures shall be consistent with the provisions of this division and shall not place any unreasonable limit on the powers and authority granted in this division. All supplementary rules and procedures shall be made available to the public at the offices of the vehicle impoundment hearing officers.
(Ord. No. 569-97, § 1, 8-25-97; Ord. No. 878-99, § 7, 11-22-99; Ord. No. 79-10, §§ 4, 5, 2-1-10)