Sec. 73.06. - Review of permits.
(a) Type of building activity. The heritage preservation commission shall review and approve or disapprove the issuance of city permits to do any of the following in a heritage preservation site in the City of Saint Paul:
(1) Remodel or repair in any manner, not including painting, that will change the exterior appearance;
(2) Construction;
(3) Move a building;
(4) Demolition; however, this does not apply to structures that are the subject of a resolution adopted by the city council requiring the demolition of the structure or that are the subject of an administrative order signed by the mayor requiring emergency demolition in accordance with Chapter 45, Legislative Code of the City of St. Paul or Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 463.
(b) City activity. The heritage preservation commission shall review and make recommendations concerning all other city activity to change the nature or appearance of a heritage preservation site, and no permit shall issue or work commence until the heritage preservation commission renders its recommendation thereon subject to the limitation specified in paragraph (f) of this section.
(c) Criteria. All decisions of the heritage preservation commission with respect to this section shall be in accordance with the approved program for the preservation of each heritage preservation site.
(d) Permit application and plans. Every application for a building permit in relation to property designated as a heritage preservation site in the City of Saint Paul shall be accompanied by detailed plans for the proposed work to be done. A copy of the application and the plans submitted therewith shall be immediately referred by the city building official to the heritage preservation commission, and permits shall not be issued until the application is approved by the heritage preservation commission, subject, however, to paragraph (f) of this section.
(e) Commission review. The heritage preservation commission, upon receipt of the application for permit and plans, shall determine if the work to be performed pursuant to the permit adversely affects the program for the preservation and architectural control of the heritage preservation site or district. If it is determined that the work to be performed pursuant to the permit application does not adversely affect the applicable program, the application shall be approved and the city building official notified in writing. The commission, or a subcommittee of the commission, or the head of the division of planning or his designee in the case of a permit application for which the commission has delegated its authority for review and approval, may approve the application subject to such conditions as may reasonably advance the purposes of this section and the applicable preservation program. If the application is not approved, the heritage preservation commission shall conduct a public hearing for the purpose of determining whether the work to be performed adversely affects the applicable program. Notice of the public hearing shall have been published in a newspaper of general circulation and sent to the permit applicant at least ten (10) days prior to the date of the hearing. The heritage preservation commission shall review the permit application and such plans as submitted therewith and, after receiving recommendations from concerned citizens, shall render its decision thereon as a written order to the city building official. No permit shall issue in regard to any application for a permit required under this section to be submitted to the heritage preservation commission until the city building official shall receive the order from the heritage preservation commission, subject, however, to paragraph (f) of this section. The commission shall furnish the permit applicant with a copy of the commission's written order and decision, together with a copy of any recommendations for changes necessary to be made before the commission will reconsider the applicant's permit application.
Any fees for heritage preservation commission review of building permit applications and plans shall be established by resolution of the city council. Such resolution may provide for waiver or refund of such fee under specific circumstances.
(f) Limitations. If within sixty (60) days from the filing of a building permit application the commission has neither approved nor denied the building permit application, the plans and permit application shall be deemed to have been approved by the commission, and if all other requirements of the city have been met, the division shall authorize a permit for the proposed work. No permit shall issue or work commence in the event the commission disapproves the application in accordance with this section.
(g) Emergency repair. In emergency situations where immediate repair is needed to protect the safety of the structure and its inhabitants, the city building official may approve the repair without prior heritage preservation commission action. In the case of a permit issued pursuant to this paragraph, the city building official shall immediately notify the heritage preservation commission and specify the facts or conditions constituting the emergency situation.
(h) Appeal to city council. The permit applicant or any party aggrieved by the decision of the heritage preservation commission shall, within fourteen (14) days of the date of the heritage preservation commission's order and decision, have a right to appeal such order and decision to the city council. The appeal shall be deemed perfected upon receipt by the division of planning of two (2) copies of a notice of appeal and statement setting forth the grounds for the appeal. The division of planning shall transmit one copy of the notice of appeal and statement to the city council and one copy to the heritage preservation commission. The commission, in any written order denying a permit application, shall advise the applicant of the right to appeal to the city council and include this paragraph in all such orders.
Any fee established by resolution of the city council shall be paid by the appellant at the time the notice of appeal is filed. Such resolution may provide for waiver or refund of such fee under specific circumstances.
(i) Factors to be considered. Before approving any permit application required under paragraph (d) of this section to be approved by the heritage preservation commission, the commission shall make findings based on the program for the preservation and architectural control for the heritage preservation site in regard to the following:
(1) In the case of a proposed alteration or addition to an existing building, that such alteration or addition will not materially impair the architectural or historic value of the building, and shall make written findings considering the existing structures and existing exterior appearance, building height, building width, depth or other dimensions, roof style, type of building materials, ornamentation, paving and setback.
(2) In the case of the proposed demolition of a building, prior to approval of said demolition, the commission shall make written findings on the following: Architectural and historical merit of the building, the effect of the demolition on surrounding buildings, the effect of any proposed new construction on the remainder of the building (in case of partial demolition) and on surrounding buildings, and the economic value or usefulness of the building as it now exists or if altered or modified in comparison with the value or usefulness of any proposed structures designated to replace the present building or buildings.
(3) In the case of a proposed new building, that such building will not in itself, or by reason of its location on the site, materially impair the architectural or historic value of buildings on adjacent sites or in the immediate vicinity within the historic preservation site.
(j) Documentation. In cases where the commission approves a permit application for demolition, partial demolition, moving or substantial alteration of a designated site or structure within a designated district, the commission may require that said site or structure(s) be documented, at the owner's expense, according to the documentation standards of the Historic American Building Survey and the Historic American Engineering Record (HABS/HAER) for deposit with the commission and the Minnesota Historical Society prior to the demolition, move or alteration.
(k) Permit time limit. No order of the heritage preservation commission or city council approving the issuance of building permits under this section shall be valid for a period longer than one year, unless a building permit is obtained within such period and work is proceeding within the terms of such permit unless the heritage preservation commission grants an extension not to exceed one year. In granting such extension, the heritage preservation commission may decide to hold a public hearing.
(Ord. No. 16772, 3-19-81; Ord. No. 17696, § 1, 11-16-89; Ord. No. 17703, § 24, 1-9-90)