Review of historic use variance applications.
Saint Paul Legislative Code § 73.03.1
in effectSec. 73.03.1. - Review of historic use variance applications.
(a) Application. Any person having an ownership, leasehold, or contingent interest in the heritage preservation site is eligible to file an application with the commission to permit use of the site in a manner consistent with its historic use or a new use consistent with section 73.04(5) of this chapter, in any zoning district where such proposed use is not permitted under the current zoning classification. The application shall be filed using the format established by the commission and shall include payment of the required fee. The application shall include a description of the proposed use, and its consistency with the structure's historic use or that the new use is consistent with section 73.04(5) of this chapter. The application shall describe all necessary exterior modifications to the structure, property, and site and include an assessment of the impact of these modifications on the historic integrity of the site, and further shall describe all interior architectural features unique to the historic period. The application shall also include a site plan, photos of existing conditions and architectural plans drawn to scale showing any proposed modifications.
(b) Fees. A fee to defray the costs incurred to review a use variance application shall be paid by the applicant at the time the use variance application is filed. The application fee shall be paid to the department of planning and economic development in the amount specified under Leg. Code § 61.302(b)(14)g.
(c) Staff review. Commission staff shall review the completed application and prepare a report and recommendation for the commission. The report shall include the following findings:
(1) The proposed use is reasonable and compatible with the historic use(s) of the site or that the new use is consistent with section 73.04(5) of this chapter.
(2) The proposed use complies with the adopted preservation program, and the United States' Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, as applicable.
(3) The historic use variance is necessary to alleviate practical difficulties unique to the heritage preservation site that prevents its use in a manner consistent with its historic use or that the new use is consistent with section 73.04(5) of this chapter, and that these difficulties were not created by the applicant.
(4) The proposed use is compatible with existing uses in the surrounding area and the underlying zoning classifications in the area.
(5) The proposed use is consistent with the comprehensive plan.
(d) Commission review. The commission may conduct a public hearing on the application. After considering the report and recommendation of staff and the testimony from any public hearing, the commission shall make a recommendation to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application and shall forward the application, the report of staff, the commission's recommendation and all other materials relative to the application to the planning commission.
(e) Planning commission review. Upon receipt of the heritage preservation commission's report and recommendation, the planning commission shall hold a public hearing in compliance with the procedures under section 61.303 of this Code for the purpose of making findings regarding the application's consistency with the comprehensive plan and the application's compatibility with the underlying zoning classifications in the surrounding area. The commission shall also review any other variances of zoning code provisions that accompany the use variance application. The planning commission shall then forward the documentation and recommendation of the heritage preservation commission together with its own findings and recommendation to the city council.
(f) City council public hearing and decision. The city council shall review all materials relative to the case and shall decide by resolution whether to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application. The council shall hold a public hearing after notice of the public hearing shall have been published in a newspaper of general circulation and sent to the variance applicant at least ten (10) days prior to the date of the hearing. The council may consider any historic use or the new use provided it is consistent with section 73.04(5) of this chapter. If the council decision is other than the recommendation of the staff or the commissions, the council shall provide revised findings to support its decision.
(g) Period of decision. The decision of the city council shall be valid for a period not longer than two (2) years following the date of the council's motion of intent approving the application unless a city permit(s) is obtained within that time and/or steady progress is being made to establish the use. A use variance granted under this section shall terminate and any subsequent use of the property or premises shall be in conformance with the property's underlying zoning classification where the use permitted by the variance is destroyed by fire or other peril to the extent greater than fifty (50) percent of its estimated market value as indicated in the records of the county assessor at the time of the damage.
(Ord 15-26, § 3, 6-3-15)
Source: City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, City Charter, Legislative Code and Administrative Code (Municode Library, library.municode.com)URL: https://library.municode.com/mn/st._paul/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=PTIILECO_TITIXCIPL_CH73HEPRCO_S73.03.1REHIUSVAAPFetched: 11/1/2026
