Ignorance or mistake; reduction in grade and class of the offense
HRS §702-219
in effect702-219. Ignorance or mistake; reduction in grade and class of the offense
Although ignorance or mistake would otherwise afford a defense to the offense charged, the defense is not available if the defendant would be guilty of another offense had the situation been as the defendant supposed. In such case, however, the ignorance or mistake of the defendant shall reduce the grade and class of the offense of which the defendant may be convicted to those of the offense of which the defendant would be guilty had the situation been as the defendant supposed.
COMMENTARY ON §702-219
This section is addressed to a limited problem. A defendant
intending to commit a certain offense, may, because of reasonable ignorance or
mistake on the defendant's part, engage in conduct which (if the requisite
state of mind were present) would be sufficient for conviction of a graver
offense. It would not be fair to convict the defendant of the graver offense
(unless some reduction in penalty were made to reflect the defendant's actual
culpability) and it would not be fair to allow a complete acquittal because the
defendant intended some other offense than the one with which the defendant is
charged.
The problem may be stated by borrowing an example from the
Model Penal Code commentary:
Burglary of a
dwelling house may, for example, reasonably be treated as an offense of greater
gravity than burglary of a store; and it is not unreasonable to require
knowledge that the structure is a dwelling or at least recklessness that such
may be the case. If we conceive of a defendant who had every ground to think
that it was a store, although it actually was a dwelling, it may not be right
to hold him for the graver crime. The doctrine that when one intends a lesser
crime he may be convicted of a graver offense committed inadvertently leads to
anomalous results if it is generally applied in the penal law....
If the
defendant in the circumstances supposed is exculpated of the graver crime, it
seems clear, however, that he should not be acquitted.[1]
The Code, following the suggestion of the Model Penal Code,
resolves the dilemma by authorizing conviction for the graver offense while
limiting the sentence (the grade and class) to that authorized for the offense
which the defendant would have committed had the situation been as the
defendant supposed. This limitation reflects the defendant's limited
culpability.
__________
§702-219 Commentary:
1. M.P.C., Tentative Draft No. 4, comments at 137 (1955).
[L 1972, c 9, pt of §1; gen ch 1993]
Source: Hawaii State Legislature (capitol.hawaii.gov), via Internet Archive capturesURL: http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0702/HRS_0702-0219.htmFetched: 11/10/2026
