11-6-4. - Applications for Grant, Renewal or Modification of Franchises.
(a) Written Application:
(1) A written application shall be filed with the city for a) grant of an initial franchise; b) renewal of a franchise under 47 U.S.C. § 546(a)-(g); or c) modification of a franchise agreement pursuant to this chapter or a franchise agreement. The provisions of this section shall not apply to the issuance of an interim permit agreement, nor shall the issuance of an interim permit agreement be deemed to mean that the permittee is qualified to hold a franchise, or that the terms of the permit are adequate to serve the cable-related needs and interests of the city. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the issuance or acceptance of an interim permit shall not prejudice the rights of the holder set forth in 47 U.S.C. § 546 (a)-(g).
(2) To be acceptable for filing, a signed original of the application shall be submitted together with three copies. The application must be accompanied by the required application filing fee as set forth in subsection 11-6-4(f), B.R.C. 1981, conform to any applicable request for proposals, and contain all required information. All applications shall include the names and addresses of persons authorized to act on behalf of the applicant with respect to the application.
(3) All applications accepted for filing shall be made available by the city for public inspection.
(b) Contents of Applications: A request for proposals for the grant of a franchise, including for a renewal franchise under 47 U.S.C. § 546(c), shall require, and any application submitted (other than an application submitted pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 546(h)) shall contain, at a minimum, the following information:
(1) Name and address of the applicant and identification of the ownership and control of the applicant, including: the names and addresses of the ten largest holders of an ownership interest in the applicant and persons in the applicant's direct ownership chain and all persons with ten percent or more ownership interest in the applicant and persons in the applicant's direct ownership chain; the persons who control the applicant and persons in the applicant's direct ownership chain; and all officers and directors of the applicant and persons in the applicant's direct ownership chain;
(2) A demonstration of the applicant's technical ability to construct and/or operate the proposed cable system, including identification of key personnel;
(3) A demonstration of the applicant's legal qualifications to construct and/or operate the proposed cable system, including, without limitation, a demonstration that the applicant meets the following criteria:
(A) The applicant must be willing to comply with the provisions of this chapter and applicable laws; and to comply with such requirements of a franchise agreement as the city may lawfully require;
(B) The applicant must not have submitted an application for an initial or renewal franchise to the city, which was denied (including any appeals) on the ground that the applicant failed to propose a cable system meeting the cable-related needs and interests of the community, or as to which any challenges to such franchising decision were finally resolved (including any appeals) adversely to the applicant, within three years preceding the submission of the application;
(C) The applicant shall not be issued a franchise if it may not hold the franchise as a matter of federal law. An applicant must have, or show that it is qualified to obtain, any necessary federal or state authorizations or waivers required to operate the cable system proposed;
(D) The applicant shall not be issued a franchise if, at any time during the five years preceding the submission of the application, the applicant was convicted of any act or omission of such character that the applicant cannot be relied upon to deal truthfully with the city and the subscribers of the cable system, or to substantially comply with its lawful obligations under applicable law, including obligations under consumer protection laws and laws prohibiting anti-competitive acts, fraud, racketeering or other similar conduct;
(E) The applicant shall not be issued a franchise if it files materially misleading information in its application or intentionally withholds information that the applicant is required to provide by law; and
(F) The applicant shall not be issued a franchise if an elected official of the city holds a controlling interest in the applicant or an affiliate of the applicant.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the city shall provide an opportunity to an applicant to show that it would be inappropriate to deny it a franchise under subparagraph 11-6-4(b)(3)(D), B.R.C. 1981, by virtue of the particular circumstances surrounding the matter and the steps taken by the applicant to cure all harms flowing therefrom and prevent their recurrence, the lack of involvement of the applicant's principals, the remoteness of the matter from the operation of cable systems, or any other matter relating to the applicant's legal qualifications.
(4) A statement prepared by a certified public accountant regarding the applicant's financial ability to complete the construction and operation of the cable system proposed;
(5) A description of the applicant's prior experience in cable system ownership, construction and operation, and identification of cities and counties in which the applicant has, or has had, a cable franchise or any interest therein, provided that an applicant that holds a franchise for the city and is seeking renewal of that franchise need only provide this information for other cities and counties where its franchise is scheduled to expire in the calendar year prior to or after its application is submitted to the city;
(6) Identification of the area of the city to be served by the proposed cable system, including a description of the proposed franchise area's boundaries;
(7) A detailed description of the physical facilities proposed, including channel capacity, technical design, performance characteristics, headend and access facilities;
(8) Where applicable, a description of the construction of the proposed cable system, including an estimate of plant mileage and its location; the proposed construction schedule; a description, where appropriate, of how services will be converted from existing facilities to new facilities; and information on the availability of space in conduits including, where appropriate, an estimate of the cost of any necessary rearrangement of existing facilities;
(9) If and to the extent that rates are subject to the jurisdiction of the city under applicable law, the proposed rate structure, including projected charges for each service tier, installation, converters and all other proposed equipment or services;
(10) A demonstration of how the applicant will reasonably meet the future cable-related needs and interests of the community, including descriptions of the channels, facilities and support for public, educational and governmental use of the cable system (including institutional networks) that the applicant proposes to provide and why the applicant believes that the proposal is adequate to meet the future cable-related needs and interests of the community, taking into account the costs thereof and the potential for amortization of such costs;
(11) Pro forma financial projections for the proposed franchise term, including a statement of projected income, and a schedule of planned capital additions, with all significant assumptions explained in notes or supporting schedules;
(12) If the applicant proposes to provide cable service to a television shadow area, an agreement to comply with paragraph 11-6-5(f)(6), B.R.C. 1981;
(13) Any other information as may be reasonably necessary to demonstrate compliance with the requirements of this chapter;
(14) An affidavit or declaration of the applicant or authorized officer thereof certifying the truth and accuracy of the information in the application, acknowledging the enforceability of application commitments, and certifying that the application meets all requirements of applicable law.
(c) Application for Grant of a Franchise, Other Than a Cable Act Renewal Franchise:
(1) A person may apply for a franchise by submitting a request for issuance of a Request for Proposals ("RFP") and requesting an evaluation of its application pursuant to paragraph 11-6-4(c)(3), B.R.C. 1981. Upon receipt of a request for an RFP, the city shall, if necessary, commence a proceeding to identify the future cable-related needs and interests of the community and, upon completion of that proceeding, shall promptly issue an RFP and proposed franchise agreement, which shall be mailed to the person requesting its issuance and any existing cable system franchisee and made available to any other interested party. The applicant shall respond within the time directed by the city, providing the information and material set forth in subsection 11-6-4(b), B.R.C. 1981. The procedures, instructions and requirements set forth in the RFP shall be followed by each applicant as if set forth and required herein. The city or its designee may seek additional information from any applicant and establish deadlines for the submission of such information. An existing franchisee shall have the right to file comments regarding any applicant and any application, which shall be treated as part of the record before the city.
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 11-6-4(c)(1), B.R.C. 1981, a person may apply for an initial franchise by submitting an unsolicited application containing the information required in subsection 11-6-4(b), B.R.C. 1981, and requesting an evaluation of that application pursuant to paragraph 11-6-4(c)(3), B.R.C. 1981. Prior to evaluating that application, the city may conduct such investigations as are necessary to determine whether the application satisfies the standards set forth in paragraph 11-6-4(c)(3), B.R.C. 1981, and may seek additional applications.
(3) In evaluating an application for a franchise, the city shall consider, among other things, the following factors:
(A) The extent to which the applicant has substantially complied with the applicable law and the material terms of any existing cable franchise for the city;
(B) Whether the quality of the applicant's service under any existing franchise in the city, including signal quality, response to customer complaints, billing practices and the like, has been reasonable in light of the needs and interests of the communities served;
(C) Whether the applicant has the financial, technical and legal qualifications to hold a cable franchise;
(D) Whether the application satisfies any minimum requirements established by the city and is otherwise reasonable to meet the future cable-related needs and interests of the community, taking into account the cost of meeting such needs and interests;
(E) Whether, to the extent not considered as part of subparagraph 11-6-4(c)(3)(D), B.R.C. 1981, the applicant will provide adequate PEG use, capacity, facilities and financial support;
(F) Whether issuance of a franchise is in the public interest considering the immediate and future effect on the public rights-of-way and private property that would be used by the cable system, including the extent to which installation or maintenance as planned would require replacement of property or involve disruption of property, public services or use of the public rights-of-way; the effect of granting an overbuild franchise on the ability of any existing franchisee to meet the cable-related needs and interests of the community; and the comparative superiority or inferiority of competing applications; and
(G) Whether the approval of the application may eliminate or reduce competition in the delivery of cable service in the city.
(4) If the city finds that it is in the public interest to issue a franchise considering the factors set forth above, and subject to the applicant's negotiation of and agreement on an appropriate franchise agreement, it shall schedule a public vote on a proposed franchise. If the city denies a franchise, it will issue a written decision explaining why the franchise was denied. Prior to deciding whether or not to issue a franchise, the city may hold one or more public hearings or implement other procedures under which comments from the public on an application may be received. The city also may grant or deny a request for a franchise based on its review of an application without further proceedings and may reject any application that is incomplete or fails to respond to an RFP.
(d) Application for Grant of a Cable Act Renewal Franchise: Applications for renewal under the Cable Act shall be received and reviewed in a manner consistent with section 626 of the Cable Act, 47 U.S.C. § 546. It is the proposal submitted by a franchisee under 47 U.S.C. § 546(b), and not the request for commencement of the renewal proceedings submitted under 47 U.S.C. § 546(a), that must contain the information required under subsection 11-6-4(b), B.R.C. 1981. If neither a franchisee nor the city activates a renewal application in a timely manner, or can activate the renewal process as set forth in 47 U.S.C. § 546(a)-(g) (including, for example, if the provisions are repealed), and except as to applications submitted pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 546(h), the provisions of subsection 11-6-4(c), B.R.C. 1981, shall apply, and a renewal request shall be evaluated using the same criteria as any other request for a franchise. The following requirements shall apply to renewal requests properly submitted pursuant to the Cable Act:
(1) If the provisions of 47 U.S.C. § 546(a)-(g) are properly invoked, the city shall issue an RFP after conducting a proceeding to review the applicant's past performance and to identify future cable-related community needs and interests. The city shall promptly make available for review by the applicant the results of its review and ascertainment process. The city manager or the manager's designee shall establish deadlines and procedures for responding to the RFP, which deadlines may not be less than one hundred twenty days after the date of the RFP, may seek additional information from the applicant related to the city's evaluation of the proposal under applicable law, and shall establish deadlines for the submission of that additional information. Following receipt of the application responding to that RFP (and such additional information as may be provided in response to requests), the city council will determine that the franchise should be renewed, or make a preliminary assessment that the franchise should not be renewed. This determination shall be in accordance with the time limits established by the Cable Act. The preliminary determination shall be made by resolution. If the city council determines that the franchise should not be renewed, and the applicant that submitted the renewal application notifies the city, either in its RFP response or within thirty working days of the preliminary assessment, that it wishes to pursue any rights to an administrative proceeding it has under the Cable Act, then the city shall commence an administrative proceeding after providing prompt public notice thereof, in accordance with the Cable Act. If the city council decides preliminarily to grant renewal, it shall prepare a final franchise agreement that incorporates, as appropriate, the commitments made by the applicant in the renewal application. If the applicant accepts the franchise agreement, and the final agreement is ratified by the city council, the franchise shall be renewed. If the franchise agreement is not so accepted and ratified within the time limits established by 47 U.S.C. § 546(c)(1), renewal shall be deemed preliminarily denied, and an administrative proceeding commenced if the applicant that submitted the renewal application requests it within thirty business days of the expiration of the time limit established by 47 U.S.C. § 546(c)(1), unless the time limit is extended by mutual agreement of the city and the franchisee.
(2) If an administrative hearing is commenced pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 546(c), the applicant's renewal application shall be evaluated considering such matters as may be considered consistent with federal law. The following procedures shall apply:
(A) The city council shall, by resolution, appoint an administrative hearing officer or officers (referred to hereafter as "hearing officer"). The city council may appoint itself as hearing officer.
(B) The hearing officer may conduct a pre-hearing conference and establish appropriate pre-hearing orders. Intervention by non-parties is not authorized except to the extent required by the Cable Act.
(C) The hearing officer shall require the city and the applicant to submit prepared testimony prior to the hearing. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the applicant shall present evidence first, and the city shall present evidence second.
(D) Any reports or the transcript or summary of any proceedings conducted pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 546(a) shall be, for purposes of the administrative hearing, regarded no differently than any other evidence.
(E) The city and the franchisee shall be afforded fair opportunity for full participation in the proceeding, including the right to introduce evidence (including evidence related to issues raised in the proceeding under subsection 47 U.S.C. § 546(a)), to require the production of evidence and to question witnesses.
(F) Following completion of any hearing, the hearing officer shall require the parties to submit proposed findings of fact with respect to the matters that the city is entitled to consider in determining whether renewal ought to be granted. Based on the record of the hearing, the hearing officer shall then prepare written findings with respect to those matters, and submit those findings and conclusions and related conclusions of law to the city council and to the parties (unless the hearing officer is the city council, in which case the written findings shall constitute the final decision of the city).
(G) If the hearing officer is not the city council, the parties shall have thirty days from the date the findings are submitted to the city council to file exceptions to those findings with the city council. The city council shall thereafter issue a written decision granting or denying the application for renewal, consistent with the requirements of the Cable Act and based on the record of such proceeding. A copy of the final decision of the city council will be promptly provided to the applicant.
(H) The proceeding shall be conducted with all deliberate speed.
(I) In conducting the proceedings, and except as inconsistent with the foregoing, the hearing officer will follow the procedures as set forth in chapter 1-3, "Quasi-Judicial Hearings," B.R.C. 1981, or the successor ordinances thereto. The hearing officer or the parties may request that the city council adopt additional procedures and requirements as necessary in the interest of justice.
(J) This section does not prohibit any franchisee from submitting an informal renewal application pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 546(h), which application may be granted or denied in accordance with the provisions of 47 U.S.C. § 546(h). If such an informal renewal application is granted, then the steps specified in this section need not be taken, notwithstanding the provisions thereof.
(e) Application for Modification of a Franchise:
(1) An application for modification of a franchise agreement shall include, at minimum, the following information:
(A) The specific modification requested;
(B) The justification for the requested modification, including the impact of the requested modification on subscribers and others, and the financial impact on the applicant if the modification is approved or disapproved, demonstrated through, inter alia, submission of pro forma financial statements.
(C) A statement indicating whether the modification is sought pursuant to section 625 of the Cable Act, 47 U.S.C. § 545, and, if so, a demonstration that the requested modification meets the standards set forth in 47 U.S.C. § 545;
(D) Any other information that the applicant believes is necessary for the city to make an informed determination on the application for modification; and
(E) An affidavit or declaration of the applicant or applicant's authorized officer certifying the truth and accuracy of the information in the application, and certifying that the application is consistent with the requirements of applicable law.
(2) A request for modification submitted pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 545 shall be considered in accordance with the requirements of that section.
(f) Filing Fees: To be acceptable for filing, an application submitted after the effective date of this chapter shall be accompanied by a reasonable filing fee in an amount sufficient to cover reasonable costs incidental to the awarding or enforcement of the franchise. Such costs shall be established by resolution of the city council, subject to applicable law.
(g) Public Hearings: An applicant shall be notified of any public hearings held in connection with the evaluation of its application and shall be given an opportunity to be heard. In addition, prior to the issuance of a franchise, the city shall provide for the holding of a public hearing within the proposed franchise area, following reasonable notice to the public, at which each applicant and its application shall be examined and the public and all interested parties afforded a reasonable opportunity to be heard. Reasonable notice to the public shall include causing notice of the time and place of such hearing to be published in a newspaper of general circulation in the proposed franchise area once a week for two consecutive weeks. The first publication shall be not less than fourteen days before the day of the hearing.
(h) Consistency With Cable Act: The provisions of this section shall be read and applied so that they are consistent with section 626 of the Cable Act, 47 U.S.C. § 546.