Section 3.1.11 - Public hearing procedures.
A. General. All public hearings shall be open to the public. Members of the public shall be permitted to testify at all public hearings. A copy of the hearing procedures shall be made available at the hearing. The applicant may withdraw an application by requesting such withdrawal in writing prior to the commencement of the hearing.
B. Record of hearings. The City Clerk shall attend all hearings, and the City shall record (audio, video, or both) all hearings. The City shall retain the original recording(s) in accordance with the laws of the State of Florida, and, if requested, provide a duplicate of the recording(s).
C. Official file. All written communication received by the decision-making body, the Hearing Examiner, or staff concerning an application, the staff report on the application, any petitions or other submissions from the public, and all other documents pertaining to the application shall be filed in the official file for the application, which shall be maintained by staff. The Comprehensive Plan, the City Code of Ordinances, and the Land Development Code shall be deemed to be part of the official file. The official file shall be available for inspection during normal business hours.
D. Order of public hearings. The hearing shall, to the extent possible, be conducted as follows:
1. The Clerk shall read into the record the ordinance or resolution title and number, or the applicant's name, file number, and the subject matter to be decided if there is no ordinance or resolution.
2. For quasi-judicial hearings, the applicant, staff, and all participants requesting to speak or present evidence or both at the hearing shall be collectively sworn by an oath or affirmation by the Clerk.
3. The applicant may waive the applicant's right to an evidentiary hearing if applicant agrees with the staff recommendation and no one from the audience wishes to speak for or against the application. The decision-making body may then vote on the item or the Hearing Examiner shall rule on the matter or make a recommendation, based upon the staff report and any other materials contained within the official file. Regardless of a waiver by the applicant, a public hearing shall be held for all decisions requiring an ordinance or resolution.
4. If there is an evidentiary hearing, the order of the presentation shall be as follows, unless the Hearing Examiner or Mayor determines to proceed in a different order, taking proper consideration of fairness and due process:
a. The applicant shall make the applicant's presentation, including offering any documentary evidence, and introduce any witnesses as applicant desires. The applicant shall present the applicant's entire case in 30 minutes.
b. Staff shall have the responsibility of presenting the case on behalf of the city. The staff report on the application shall be made available by staff to the applicant and the decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner no later than five business days prior to the quasi-judicial hearing on the application. Staff shall present a brief synopsis of the application; introduce any appropriate additional exhibits from the official file that have not already been transmitted to the Hearing Examiner or City Council with the agenda materials, summarize issues; and make a recommendation on the application. Staff shall also introduce any witnesses that it wishes to provide testimony at the hearing. Staff shall present its entire case in 30 minutes.
c. Public comment. Participants in opposition to or support of the application shall make their presentation in any order as determined by the Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor. Each participant shall present their argument in five minutes.
d. For hearings on quasi-judicial matters only, the applicant may cross-examine any witness and respond to any testimony presented.
e. For hearings on quasi-judicial matters only, staff may cross-examine any witness and respond to any testimony presented.
f. The Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor may choose to allow participants to respond to any testimony if the Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor deems the response to be necessary to ensure fairness and due process.
g. Members of the Planning and Zoning Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council may ask any questions of the staff, applicant, and participants.
h. Final argument may be made by the applicant, related solely to the evidence in the record.
i. Final argument may be made by the staff, related solely to the evidence in the record.
j. For good cause shown, the Planning and Zoning Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council may grant additional time to any of the above time limitations.
k. The Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor shall keep order, and without requiring an objection, may direct a party conducting the direct examination or the cross-examination to stop a particular line of questioning that, in the sole judgment of the Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor merely harasses, intimidates, or embarrasses the individual testifying or being cross-examined; is unduly repetitious or is not relevant; or is beyond the scope of the application or, in the case of cross-examination, is beyond the scope of the testimony by the individual being cross-examined. If the party conducting the direct examination or cross-examination continues to violate directions from the Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor to end a line of questioning deemed improper as set forth herein, the Chair, Hearing Examiner, or Mayor may terminate the direct examination or the cross-examination.
l. The Planning and Zoning Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council may, on its own motion or at the request of any person, continue the hearing to a fixed date, time, and place. The applicant shall have the right to one continuance; however, all subsequent continuances shall be granted at the sole discretion of the Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council.
E. Decisions. For all quasi-judicial hearings in which a decision is made regarding an application for any development permit, the decision to approve or deny shall be based on whether the application meets all applicable requirements of the Comprehensive Plan, the City Code of Ordinances, and the Land Development Code, based on the entirety of the record before the Hearing Examiner or City Council. The Hearing Examiner or Council decisions must be based upon competent substantial evidence in the record.
F. Rules of Evidence for quasi-judicial hearings.
1. The decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner shall not be bound by the strict rules of evidence and shall not be limited only to consideration of evidence which would be admissible in a court of law. The decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner shall have the ability, but not the duty, to conduct site visits in their sole discretion and to consider any evidence so adduced in their deliberations.
2. The Chair or Hearing Examiner may exclude evidence or testimony that is not relevant, material, or competent or testimony which is unduly repetitious or defamatory.
3. The Chair, with the advice of the City Attorney, will determine the relevancy of evidence. In matters decided by the Hearing Examiner, the Hearing Examiner, without the advice of the City Attorney, will determine the relevancy of evidence.
4. Matters relating to an application's consistency with the Comprehensive Plan, the City Code of Ordinances, or the Land Development Code will be presumed to be relevant and material.
5. Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence, but it shall not be sufficient by itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in court.
6. Documentary evidence may be presented in the form of a copy of the original, if available. A copy shall be made available to the decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner and to the staff no later than three business days prior to the hearing on the application. Upon request, the applicant and staff shall be given an opportunity to compare the copy with the original. Oversized exhibits shall be copied and reduced for convenient record storage.
7. Only the applicant, an authorized representative of the applicant, staff, and the decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner shall be entitled to conduct cross-examination when testimony is given or documents are made part of the record.
8. The City Attorney shall represent the decision-making body and advise it as to procedures to be followed.
9. The Planning and Zoning Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council shall take judicial notice of all state and local laws, ordinances, and regulations and may take judicial notice of such other matters as are generally recognized by the courts of the State of Florida.
10. Supplementing the record after the quasi-judicial hearing is prohibited, unless specifically authorized by an affirmative vote of the decision-making body, or authorized by the Hearing Examiner, under the following conditions:
a. The supplementation occurs after a quasi-judicial hearing is continued but prior to final action being taken on the application or appeal.
b. If a question is raised by the Planning and Zoning Commission, Hearing Examiner, or City Council at the hearing which cannot be answered at the hearing, the party to whom the question is directed will submit the requested information in writing to the City Clerk and the decision-making body or Hearing Examiner after the quasi-judicial hearing, with copies to the other parties, provided the hearing has been continued or another hearing has been scheduled for a future date and no final action has been taken by the decision-making body or Hearing Examiner. The information requested will be presented to the decision-making body or the Hearing Examiner at least two business days prior to the time of the continued hearing.
c. All parties and participants shall have the same right with respect to the additional information as they had for evidence presented at the hearing.
G. Final decision. The City Council or the Hearing Examiner shall reach a written decision without unreasonable or unnecessary delay. The Hearing Examiner shall provide a copy of the decision to the City Clerk for transmission to the applicant, if the applicant is not the City, to the Director of the Department of Community Development, and the City Attorney.
H. The Record. All evidence admitted into the record at the hearing, the official file, and the adopted development order, ordinance, or resolution of the City Council or the written decision of the Hearing Examiner shall be maintained by the City Clerk or the Department of Community Development.
I. Adjournment. The Chairperson, upon a vote of the majority present, or Hearing Examiner, as applicable, may adjourn a hearing to a date certain without the necessity of additional notice. Adjournment to an uncertain date shall require notice as required for the original hearing and by the Land Development Code.
J. Deferrals. If a hearing is concluded, but action is deferred until a future date, formal notice shall not be required prior to action being taken.
K. Joint hearings. Where deemed necessary, joint hearings may be conducted after proper public notice. In such instances, public notice need only be given by one public body, which shall be the City Council in instances where it is one of the hearing bodies.
L. Regularly scheduled public hearing dates. The Hearing Examiner or the City Council may establish regular dates for public hearings on zoning amendments. Such dates, if established by the Hearing Examiner, or the City Council, shall not prevent the Hearing Examiner or City Council from scheduling additional public hearings whenever such public hearings are deemed necessary.
M. Reading of ordinances. Except for ordinances initiated by the City Council which rezone a parcel or parcels of land involving ten or more contiguous acres, or change permitted, special exception, or prohibited use categories in zoning districts, all ordinances shall be read, either by title or in full, on two separate days at a duly noticed public hearing of the City Council.
N. The printed agenda for the meeting at which the quasi-judicial hearing is scheduled to take place shall identify the hearing as quasi-judicial and indicate where copies of the procedures that apply may be obtained.