SEC. 15-1505. - FAÇADE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS.
A. Building Articulation and Massing.
1. Building Length Articulation. All building facades over 50 feet in length which face a street, public plaza, or park shall be designed with a minimum of two of the following façade articulation strategies:
a. Material Articulation. Utilize different materials to divide building façades into vertical and/or horizontal increments.
b. Structural Expression. Express building bays, structural elements such as columns and/or beams, or underlying structural elements with pilasters and lintels that project several inches from the façade and/or are clad in a different material from the façade.
c. Horizontal Articulation. Setback a portion of the street-facing façade a minimum of two feet for a minimum distance of 25 feet.
d. Architectural Projections. Append or project façade elements such as balconies, bay windows, cantilevered rooms, and/or awnings.
e. Architectural Recessions. Recess architectural elements or spaces—such as recessed porches, covered passages, recessed balconies, and windows—into the plane of the façade.
2. Building Height Articulation. In order to maintain a human scale for multi-story buildings, the height of façades which face a street, public plaza, or park shall be broken into smaller increments as follows:
a. Ground Floors. A substantial horizontal articulation of the façade shall be applied at the top of the first story. On buildings of five stories or taller, this articulation may be applied at the top of the second story. This element shall be no less than 18 inches tall, and shall project no less than four inches from the adjacent wall plane. It shall be designed as a cornice, belt course, or other such architectural element which is appropriate to the style of the building.
b. Top Floor. Buildings or portions of buildings which are four stories in height or taller shall also provide articulation for the top story of the building. This can be accomplished by a color change, material change, a cornice/belt course at the bottom of the uppermost story, or by stepping the uppermost story back at least five feet. On buildings of 8 stories or taller, this articulation may be applied to the top two stories.
c. Ground Floor/Upper Floor Differentiation. Ground floor facades shall be distinct from upper floors through the use or finish of materials, colors, window sizes, or architectural details.
d. Exception. Civic and Cultural buildings located in the Downtown General (DTG) District may be excepted as determined by the Review Authority.
[image omitted; see the official code]
FIGURE 15-1505-A.2: BUILDING HEIGHT ARTICULATION
B. Building Materials and Finishes.
1. General Standards.
a. Each side of a building that is visible from a street, public plaza, park, or passenger railway shall be designed with a complementary level of detailing and quality of materials.
b. Each side of a parking structure that is visible from a street, public plaza, park, or passenger railway shall be designed to be compatible with the architectural character, materials, and colors of the overall development.
c. Durability of Materials. Exterior materials shall be durable and promote permanence and longevity. Applicants must demonstrate that materials will not unintentionally discolor due to weathering or corrosion. Materials that discolor naturally, such as copper, are encouraged.
d. Design Consistency.
i. Finishes, fixtures, and other architectural details shall be designed to be consistent throughout the building.
ii. Attached architectural elements and details such as lighting fixtures, attic vents, custom signage, awnings, hand rails, balconies, and trellises shall be designed to be consistent with other elements throughout the building. Such elements shall relate to the elements or intended general character of surrounding significant resources, potentially significant resources, and other historic-era buildings.
[image omitted; see the official code]
Many of Fresno's cherished historic buildings have articulated upper and lower floors.
[image omitted; see the official code]
Contemporary buildings can also exhibit building height articulation.
e. Multiple Materials.
i. Two or more wall materials may be combined on one façade.
ii. A minimum of two exterior wall finish materials shall be used for all mixed-use buildings with a commercial ground floor.
iii. If located one above the other, lighter appearing materials shall be placed above more substantial materials (e.g., wood above stucco or masonry, or stucco and glass above masonry).
iv. In general, vertical joints between different materials shall occur only at inside corners.
2. Stucco.
a. Finishes should be smooth and troweled.
b. The pattern of joints should be architecturally coordinated with the overall façade composition, and sealant colors should be coordinated with surface and other building colors.
3. Exposed Wood.
a. Exterior walls that are or were originally clad in exposed wood shall not be covered with a non-wood material. Wood-like materials, such as cementitious siding, may be used.
b. Exposed wood (or wood-like materials) shall be finished in a manner that minimizes maintenance and promotes the material's longevity.
4. Reflective Materials. Reflective materials, such as polished metal cladding or chrome, are allowed only if:
a. The material is applied to small areas such as to highlight signage.
b. It can be demonstrated that the material will not result in an incompatible adjacency or cause a nuisance to pedestrians, vehicles, and neighboring buildings.
5. Masonry and Stone.
a. Masonry veneer walls shall be detailed with structural integrity, appearing thicker and heavier, especially at corners and window and door openings.
b. Brick and cut stone shall be laid in true bonding patterns. Mortar joints shall be struck.
c. River and rubble stone shall be laid from large closest to the ground to small farthest from the ground, with smooth or beaded mortar joints.
d. Masonry detailing shall transition from stone to other materials through moldings, caps, and other trim elements.
6. Veneers. Veneers should turn corners, avoiding exposed edges and continue down the side of a building to a logical break, such as a change in wall plane. Corner pieces should be mitered to hide the joint.
7. Trim. Trim materials and finishes shall be differentiated from adjacent wall cladding materials and finishes. Acceptable trim materials shall be wood, precast concrete, stone, tile, or similar materials. Stucco trim shall be permitted at the determination of the Review Authority, and in such instances it shall feature a smooth finish that contrasts significantly from adjacent stucco wall cladding.
8. Synthetic Materials. The use of synthetic materials is allowed when the Review Authority determines that the material:
a. Adequately simulates the appearance of the natural material it imitates.
b. Demonstrates an ability to age similar to or better than the natural material it imitates.
c. Has a permanent texture, color, and character that is acceptable for the proposed application.
d. Can be pressure washed and, in general, withstand anti-graffiti measures.
9. Prohibited Materials. Prohibited exterior materials include the following:
a. T1-11.
b. Rough-sawn wood.
c. Vertical siding.
d. Board and batten.
e. Metal siding, except in the DTN zone.
f. Concrete block as an exterior finish material, except in the DTN zone.
g. Plywood, particle board, press board, and similar materials.
10. Signage Design. Building signage shall be designed to complement the building while providing adequate visibility from and maintaining compatibility with adjacent suites/units on upper floors near the signage.
11. Renovations and Alterations.
a. Modifications to existing buildings shall be architecturally compatible with the existing building as determined by the Review Authority.
b. Exterior walls that are or were originally clad in wood, masonry, or stone shall not be covered with a different material such as stucco.
c. Renovations or alterations to "modernized" pre-World War II buildings shall restore the original façade materials, textures, fenestration, and ornamentation to the extent possible as determined by the Review Authority.
12. Exception. Civic and Cultural buildings located in the Downtown General (DTG) District may be excepted from the standards of this subsection as determined by the Review Authority.
C. Window and Door Opening Design.
1. Consistency with Architectural Style. The orientation and proportion of openings shall be consistent with the architectural style of the building and shall relate to one another proportionally and according to a rational system of design. For example, buildings designed according to traditional architectural styles typically have window openings and panes that are vertically oriented or square or composed of groupings of vertically oriented windows. Mixed-use buildings can have second floor windows that are grouped and centered above the ground floor storefront doors and windows.
2. Glazing Ratio.
a. Upper floor façades, and non-commercial portions of ground floor street-facing façades, which face a street, public plaza, or park shall comply with the following requirements for openings:
TABLE 15-1505-C-2-A: GLAZING STANDARDS
Standard | DTN | DTG | DTC
Min. percentage of upper floor façades that shall consist of openings such as windows and doors to balconies or roofdecks. | 25 | 25 | 25
Max. percentage of upper floor façades that shall consist of openings such as windows and doors to balconies or roofdecks. Curtain wall systems are allowed as a primary cladding system in the DTG district, and as an accent in the DTN and DTC districts. | 70 | 100 | 70
b. Ground Floor Commercial Transparency.
i. For ground floor façades which face a street, public plaza, or park on portions of a structure occupied by commercial uses, exterior walls facing a front or street side lot line shall include windows, doors, or other openings with transparent glazing for at least 60 percent of the building wall area located between 1.5 and seven feet above the level of the sidewalk.
ii. Openings fulfilling this requirement shall have transparent glazing without reflective glass frosting or dark tinting (to the maximum extent permitted by Title 24 and other energy efficiency regulations) and provide views into work areas, display areas, sales areas, lobbies, or similar active spaces, or into window displays that are at least two feet deep.
[image omitted; see the official code]
FIGURE 15-1505-C-2-B: GROUND FLOOR COMMERCIAL TRANSPARENCY
3. Vertical Proportion. On upper stories, window openings shall have a vertical proportion, in which their height exceeds their width by 25 percent or more. Openings divided by muntins of four inches or more in width shall constitute separate openings.
4. Window Depth. Trim at least one inch in depth must be provided around all upper story windows, or windows must be recessed at least two inches from the plane of the surrounding exterior wall. For double-hung and horizontal sliding windows, at least one sash shall achieve the two-inch recess.
5. Bay Windows. Bay windows, if provided, shall be habitable spaces.
6. Window and Door Materials and Detailing.
a. Allowed window and door materials include wood, fiberglass, steel, or aluminum.
b. Muntins, if used, shall be true and divide one pane from the adjoining pane, be of substantial dimension, and not be flat.
c. Flush "nail-on" aluminum windows, and horizontal aluminum sliding windows are prohibited.
d. Vinyl and vinyl clad windows shall be consistent with the architectural style of the building. For example, windows of Craftsman style buildings should be brown or hunter's green, not white.
e. Glazing shall be clear glass (to the maximum extent permitted by Title 24 and other energy efficiency regulations), particularly in storefront and primary window applications. Transom, clerestory, and other specialty windows are not required to be clear and may be decorative.
f. Window sills shall be detailed to properly shed water.
g. Head casing shall be equal in width to or wider than jamb casing.
h. Accessories may include operable shutters sized to match their openings, opaque canvas awnings and other shading devices, and planter boxes supported by visible brackets appropriate to each design.
i. Security bars and roll down security doors are prohibited on the outside of windows and doors which face a street, public plaza, or park. Retractable interior security bars or gates may be used.
7. Exception. With the exception of Section 1505-C.2.b, Civic and Cultural buildings located in the Downtown General (DTG) District may be excepted from the standards of this subsection as determined by the Review Authority.
D. Façade Alignment.
1. Vertical Alignment. With the exception of mansard roofs, cornices, and other such features, façades shall be oriented vertically and shall have no slope.
2. Horizontal Alignment. With the exception of bay windows and similar features, façades that are located within 30 feet of a public street or public plaza shall run parallel or perpendicular to said street or plaza.
3. Exception. Civic and Cultural buildings located in the Downtown General (DTG) District may be excepted from the standards of this subsection as determined by the Review Authority.
E. External Stairs and Corridors.
1. External Stairways. With the exception of stoops and similar steps intended for access for ground-floor spaces, external stairways shall not be located between the primary façade of the building and a public street. Within 30 feet of a public street, stairs shall be architecturally integrated into the building and shall not have open risers.
2. External Corridors. External upper-floor corridors located within 30 feet of a public street shall be architecturally integrated into the building.
F. Private Frontage. Uses shall be accessed through frontage types as follows. "P" means the frontage type is permitted. "-" means the frontage type is not permitted.
TABLE 15-1505-e-1: PERMITTED PRIVATE FRONTAGE TYPES
Use Classification | Front Yard | Porch | Stoop | Loading Dock/Terrace | Shopfront | Forecourt | Grand Entry | None
Residential, Individual Entry | P | P | P | — | — | — | — | —
Residential, Common Entry | P | — | — | — | — | P | P | —
Public and Semi-Public | P | — | — | — | P | P | P | —
Commercial, Individual Entry | — | — | — | P | P | — | — | —
Commercial, Common Entry | — | — | — | — | P | P | P | —
Industrial | — | — | — | P | P | P | P | P
Transportation, Communication, and Utilities | — | — | — | — | — | P | P | P
Service Areas | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | P
TABLE 15-1505-E-2: PRIVATE FRONTAGE STANDARDS
A. Front Yard
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 5 ft. min.
ⓑ Length: 15 ft. min.
ⓒ Height above Sidewalk: 3 ft. max.
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Planters, garden walls, fences and hedges are permitted at the sidewalk to a maximum height of 3 ft.. Materials and design shall be compatible with the architectural style of the building.
b. Water features, shade structures, seating, and gardens are encouraged in this area.
c. Vehicular parking, trash collection and storage are not permitted in this area.
d. When Front Yards are raised from the level of the sidewalk, the resulting retaining wall shall be decorative and clad in brick or stone.
B. Porch
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 5 ft. min., 15 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 8 ft. min.
ⓒ Height above adjacent grade: 18 in. min., 4 ft. max.
ⓓ Height: 8 ft. min. clear from the finish floor
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Provide landscaping in front of and around porch.
b. Railings should be no higher than required by the building code.
c. The porch may extend around to encroach into the street sideyard up to ½ of the required setback. If insufficient distance exists, the minimum porch depth shall be achieved by moving back the façade the necessary distance.
d. Awnings may be attached to the face of the porch if the awning is adequately supported and if the awning is compatible with the architectural style of the porch and building.
e. Porches shall not be enclosed except for insect screens between the structural members of the porch if:
i. Visibility is not reduced between the adjacent sidewalk and the porch.
ii. The insect screen is recessed from the front face of the columns on the porch.
C. Stoop
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 6 ft. min., 15 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 4 ft. min., 10 ft. max.
ⓒ Height: Max. 4 ft. elevation above finish sidewalk grade
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Landscaping encouraged in front, around and/or within walls of stoop.
b. Minimum 3 ft. to maximum 4 ft. high garden wall and gate may be provided at entry to stoop.
c. Entry gates to swing in a direction away from sidewalk.
d. Use of other frontage types at entry stoop (e.g., awning, bay window, arcade) allowed.
e. Exterior stairs may be located perpendicular or parallel to the adjacent sidewalk.
f. The landing may be covered or uncovered, but shall not be enclosed beyond the building façade (e.g., stoop landings may be recessed into the building façade and be enclosed by the walls of the recess).
D. Loading Dock/Terrace
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 7 ft. min.
ⓑ Length: no min./no max.
ⓒ Height: Max. 4 ft. elevation above finish sidewalk grade
ⓓ Railing Height: no higher than required by the Building Code
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Exterior stairs may be perpendicular or parallel to the adjacent sidewalk but shall not encroach into the right-of-way. The landing may be covered or uncovered.
E. Storefront
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Depth of Recessed Storefront Dining Area: 12 ft. max.
ⓑ Depth of Shop: 30 ft. min.
ⓒ Length: min. 75% of required façade length
ⓓ Height above sidewalk: must be at sidewalk grade
ⓔ Bulkhead Height: 18 in. min., 3 ft. max.
2. Supplemental Standards
a. A physical transition or 'bulkhead' shall be provided between the glazing of any storefront and the adjacent sidewalk. The bulkhead shall not consist of aluminum storefront or spandrel panel.
b. Storefront windows may have clerestory windows between the storefront and second floor/top of single-story parapet. Glass in clerestory windows may be of a character to allow light, while moderating it such as stained glass, glass block, painted glass, or frosted glass.
c. Storefronts shall provide clear views of merchandise displays within the shop space and/or maintained and lighted merchandise display(s) within a display zone of at least two feet in depth from the glass.
d. The storefront may be directly illuminated from the sidewalk side of the glass by externally mounted lights.
e. Planter boxes, containers or vine pockets may be located adjacent to storefronts. Such landscape areas shall not be located within required ADA access ways along any public sidewalk.
[image omitted; see the official code]
This diagram shows how the various components of a storefront can be arranged.
F. Forecourt
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 15 ft. min.; 50% of lot depth max.
ⓑ Length: 12 ft. min.; 50% of lot depth max..
ⓒ Height: 4 ft. max. above adjacent sidewalk
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Elevated forecourts shall meet the accessibility code for access to the building and the sidewalk. Railings shall not visually obstruct views to or from the street and shall be designed to match the architectural style of the main building.
b. Arcades, galleries, awnings, or canopies may encroach into the forecourt for a distance of ¼ of the forecourt width or depth with a cumulative encroachment not to exceed a combined distance of ½ of the forecourt width and depth, respectively.
c. Planters, garden walls, fences and hedges are permitted at the entrance to the forecourt to a maximum height of 3 ft. per Section 15-2006, Fences, Walls, and Hedges.
d. Water features, shade structures, seating, and gardens are encouraged in this area.
e. Vehicular parking, trash collection and storage are not permitted in this area.
G. Grand Entry
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 6 ft. min., 15 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 10 ft. min., 25 ft. max.
ⓒ Height: May be at sidewalk grade, or max. 4 ft. elevation above finish sidewalk grade
2. Supplemental Standards
a. The entrance shall be clearly differentiated from entrances into individual commercial or residential spaces through the use of decorative columns or similar ornamentation flanking the entrance, by aligning the entrance with prominent architectural features on upper floors, or through color and material changes.
b. The entrance shall be covered by an awning or canopy or shall be recessed into the building.
G. Façade Elements. The following development types shall incorporate a minimum of two of the Façade Elements shown in Table 15-1505-F into front and street-side building façades.
1. New buildings.
2. Building additions (façade elements are not required on the existing part of the structure if it is not being altered).
3. Façade remodels.
4. Exceptions:
a. Projects or parts of projects involving designated historic resources, or the restoration of historic façades, shall not be required to incorporate Façade Elements if such elements were not part of the historic façade.
b. Civic and Cultural buildings located in the Downtown General (DTG) District may be excepted from the standards of this subsection as determined by the Review Authority.
TABLE 15-1505-F: FAÇADE ELEMENTS—DOWNTOWN DISTRICTS
A. Gallery
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 10 ft. min., 15 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 50% to 100% of building length
ⓒ Height: 8 ft. min. clear from the finish floor
ⓓ Encroachment into R.O.W.: Galleries may encroach over the sidewalk in the public right-of-way, subject to an encroachment permit prior to issuance of a building permit as follows:
• 10—12 ft. wide sidewalk: 6 ft. max.
• 12—14 ft. wide sidewalk: 8 ft. max.
• 14+ ft. wide sidewalk: ⅔ width of sidewalk max.
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Planter boxes or pots may be placed in between the columns to provide enclosure for uses such as café seating. A Gallery must be a minimum 50% open on two sides.
b. Balconies, awnings, bay windows, verandas, or other structures are allowed above the gallery.
c. Except on residential and civic buildings, Galleries shall be combined with the Storefront frontage type.
d. Column spacing and colonnade detailing, including lighting, shall be consistent with the style of the building to which it is attached.
e. Columns shall be placed in relation to curbs so as to allow passage around and to allow for passengers of cars to exit the vehicle.
B. Arcade
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Clear Depth: 10 ft. min., 15 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 50% to 100% of building length
ⓒ Height: 8 ft. min. clear from the finish floor
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Planter boxes or pots may be placed in between the columns to provide enclosure for uses such as café seating.
b. Arcade to be a minimum 50% open on two sides.
c. Balconies, awnings, bay windows, verandas, or other structures are allowed above the arcade.
d. Column spacing and colonnade detailing, including lighting, shall be consistent with the style of the building to which it is attached.
C. Bay Window
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Depth: 2 ft. min., 4 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 15 ft. max.
ⓒ Height: 2nd fl.: 10 ft. min. clear from the ground
ⓓ Encroachment into R.O.W.: 3 ft. max.
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Bay windows are permitted on the ground floor of buildings with residential ground floors.
b. Provide landscape in front and around bay windows on the ground floor.
c. Bay windows to have a minimum 25% glazing.
D. Balcony
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Depth: 5 ft. min., 10 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 8 ft. min.
ⓒ Height: 8 ft. min. clear, 12 ft. max. clear from the finish floor
ⓓ Encroachment into Setback or R.O.W.: 4 ft. max.
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Balcony may be covered but should be a minimum 50% open on three sides.
E. Awning, Canopy, Marquee, Sun Shade, Trellis
1. Basic Standards | [image omitted; see the official code]
ⓐ Depth: 2 ft. min., 10 ft. max.
ⓑ Length: 25% to 75% of building frontage
ⓒ Height: 8 ft. min. clear from the ground
ⓓ Encroachment into Setback or R.O.W.: within 2 ft. clear of curb
2. Supplemental Standards
a. Awnings, Canopies, Sun Shades, and Trellises shall not cover the entire length of the facade. They may cover individual storefronts and openings or multiple openings as follows:
• Storefront(s) within 5 feet of another storefront.
• Up to 2 doors or windows not associated with a storefront if the distance between them does not exceed 3 feet.
b. Awnings, Canopies, Sun Shades, and Trellises shall not obscure architectural features such as moldings above the storefront.
c. Awnings shall match the shape of the opening they are shading (simple shed shaped awnings for rectangular openings) except for odd shaped awnings. Odd shaped and bubble awnings are prohibited except where a photograph shows they have been previously allowed on the building and were not in conflict with an applicable requirement.
d. Awnings, Canopies, Sun Shades, and Trellises may be constructed of metal, wood or fabric. Highly reflective materials should be avoided.
e. Lights that illuminate the pedestrian way or sidewalk dining beneath the awning are only allowed upon review and determination by the Director that the proposed lighting is appropriate for the context and consistent with the intended physical character of the zoning district.
f. Internally illuminated awnings that glow are prohibited.
(Added Ord. 2016-43, § 2, eff. 12-9-16).