12.5.1204: ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING PROCEDURES:
A. Request For Informal Conference By User: After issuance of an FNOV or NOV or a unilateral administrative order, the user may request an informal conference with the Chief Executive Officer to resolve issues in the notice or order. The request must be submitted to the Chief Executive Officer in writing within five (5) calendar days of receipt of the notice or order or prior to the date upon which corrective action has been ordered, whichever comes first. The Chief Executive Officer shall hold the informal conference within ten (10) calendar days of receipt of the request for the informal conference. The notice or unilateral administrative order may be modified or reissued as a consent administrative order after resolution of issues in the informal conference, within fifteen (15) calendar days of the informal conference.
B. Request For Hearing By User:
1. The user may request a hearing after receipt of a unilateral administrative order, emergency suspension order, or imminent hazard order within the following time periods:
a. Any request for hearing must be submitted in writing to the Chief Executive Officer within fifteen (15) calendar days after receipt of a unilateral administrative order (if no hearing has been previously held). If an informal conference is requested and held, the time period for requesting a hearing is extended to within five (5) calendar days of the informal conference. In no event may a written request for a hearing be submitted beyond thirty (30) calendar days following receipt of a unilateral administrative order.
b. Any request for hearing must be submitted in writing to the Chief Executive Officer within five (5) calendar days after receipt of an emergency suspension order or imminent hazard order.
2. The user may request a stay of requirements (including payment of administrative fines) in a written request for hearing regarding a unilateral administrative order. A stay of the requirements may be granted at the discretion of the Hearing Officer considering hardship on user, whether an ongoing violation is occurring, potential adverse effects of ongoing violation, and certainty of violation. No stay of requirements is available regarding an emergency suspension order or imminent hazard order.
3. If a request for a hearing is filed, a hearing shall be held within a reasonable time.
4. If the hearing is not requested within the specified time periods, the FNOV, NOV, unilateral administrative order, or emergency suspension order is final.
5. Submission of a request for a hearing in no way relieves the user of liability for any violations occurring before or after receipt of the FNOV, NOV or order.
C. Hearing Initiated By Chief Executive Officer: Prior to any NOV or formal order, the Chief Executive Officer may order to appear at a public hearing any user which causes or contributes to violation of this article, control mechanism, BMP or order issued hereunder, to show cause to the Chief Executive Officer, why a proposed enforcement action should not be taken. Notice shall be served on the user specifying the time and place for the public hearing; the proposed enforcement action and the reasons for the action, including any alleged violation and the facts constituting the violation, and a request that the user show cause why the proposed enforcement action should not be taken. The notice of the hearing shall be served personally or by registered or certified mail (return receipt requested) at least fifteen (15) days prior to the hearing; except that the Chief Executive Officer may set an earlier date for hearing if it is requested by the alleged violator. The notice may be served on any principal executive, general partner or corporate officer. Whether or not a duly notified user appears as noticed, immediate enforcement action may be pursued.
D. Hearing Procedures:
1. Hearing Officer:
a. Upon request for a hearing, the Chief Executive Officer may act as Hearing Officer or may designate, in writing and/or by administrative regulation, employees of the City and Utilities or third parties as Hearing Officers. No Hearing Officer shall be responsible to or subject to the supervision or direction of any officer, employee, or agent engaged in the performance or investigatory or prosecuting functions for the Chief Executive Officer.
b. Upon the filing in good faith by a party of a timely and sufficient affidavit of personal bias by a Hearing Officer, the Hearing Officer shall rule upon the allegations as part of the record in the administrative proceedings. A Hearing Officer may at any time withdraw if he/she deems him/herself disqualified or for any other good reason, in which case the Chief Executive Officer promptly shall designate a new Hearing Officer.
2. Representation: Utilities or the City shall be represented by an attorney from the Utilities general counsel's office, Office of the City Attorney or outside counsel hired by either office. The alleged violator may be represented by counsel or may proceed pro se. At the Hearing Officer's discretion, an attorney who is from the Utilities general counsel's office, Office of the City Attorney or outside counsel hired by either office and who is different from the Attorney representing Utilities or the City, may advise the Hearing Officer regarding any procedural questions during the hearing.
3. Prehearing And Hearing Procedures:
a. Hearing Officer Authority: The Hearing Officer shall have authority to administer oaths and affirmations; sign and issue subpoenas; rule upon evidentiary objections and offers of proof; dispose of motions, including, without limitation, motions pertaining to discovery, jurisdiction, dismissal, procedure, consolidation and intervention; regulate prehearing proceedings and schedule; regulate the conduct and timing of the hearing; exclude from the hearing any person for any improper conduct; and award attorney fees for abuses of discovery or as otherwise provided in the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure.
b. Prehearing Scheduling Order: The Hearing Officer shall timely issue a prehearing scheduling order to the parties. The order shall contain a discovery schedule; prehearing motion schedule; date by which persons, experts, documents, expert reports and tangible things will be identified; date for prehearing conference, if any; date for hearing management order, if any, and hearing date.
c. Discovery: To the extent practicable, Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure 29 and 30, regarding depositions, apply to hearings conducted under this article. The parties retain their rights under the Colorado Open Records Act and the Chief Executive Officer retains its inspection and enforcement authorities under this article during the pendency of the proceedings and the Hearing Officer shall not abridge these rights.
d. Subpoenas: Upon oral or written request of any party, a Hearing Officer shall sign a subpoena or subpoena duces tecum requiring the attendance of a witness or the production of documentary evidence, or both at a deposition or hearing. Compliance with any subpoena issued may be enforced by application of the Hearing Officer to the Municipal Court of the City, where enforcement may be in the same manner as contempt of court is enforced pursuant to section 11.3.113 of this Code.
e. Settlement Conferences: At any time after a proceeding is initiated, any party may request a settlement conference. If the Hearing Officer grants the request, the conference shall be conducted by a third party, paid for equally by all parties. All discussions at the settlement conference shall not be disclosed to the Hearing Officer and are governed by Colorado Rule of Evidence 408. A Hearing Officer may require a settlement conference on his/her own motion.
f. Settlements: The Hearing Officer shall be notified promptly of all settlements, stipulations, Chief Executive Officer orders or any other action terminating the matter. Approval by the Hearing Officer is not required.
g. Ex Parte Communications: No ex parte material representation of any kind offered without notice shall be received or considered by the Hearing Officer. Copies of all pleadings or correspondence filed with, or directed to, the Hearing Officer by any party shall be served upon all other parties.
h. Evidence: Except with respect to rule 408, the Hearing Officer shall not be bound by the Colorado Rules of Evidence. The Hearing Officer may exclude evidence if such evidence does not possess the probative value commonly accepted by reasonable and prudent people in the conduct of their affairs. The Hearing Officer shall give effect to the rules of privilege recognized by law. The Hearing Officer may exclude incompetent and repetitious evidence. Upon request, a party shall be given the opportunity to compare a copy of documentary evidence with the original.
i. Continuances: Continuances are discouraged and shall be granted only upon a showing of good cause. Motions for continuance must be filed in a timely manner. Stipulations for a continuance shall not be effective unless and until approved by the Hearing Officer.
j. Prehearing Conference And Hearing Management Order: The Hearing Officer may request that the parties provide a hearing management order in the form provided by CRCP 16(C)(1). The Hearing Officer may enter the hearing management order with or without a prehearing conference.
k. Conduct Of Hearing: The Hearing Officer may request that the parties, prior to the hearing, identify witnesses and submit any documentary or demonstrative evidence or expert reports, which may be presented at the hearing. The Hearing Officer shall establish a procedure for conduct of the hearing, which shall allow for an orderly presentation by all parties. The Hearing Officer shall permit all parties to respond to the request for hearing, to present evidence and argument on all issues, and to conduct cross examination required for full disclosure of the facts.
l. File And Hearings Open To The Public: If a hearing is held pursuant to this article, all items filed with the Hearing Officer and the hearing shall be open to the public.
4. Evidence: A verbatim record of the proceedings shall be made by electronic recording device or other more appropriate method. The Hearing Officer shall mark any documentation or demonstrative evidence received and shall maintain the evidence. The transcript, if prepared, and other evidence will be made available to any person upon payment of charges.
5. Hearing Record: For purposes of the decision, the record shall include all pleadings, applications, testimony, exhibits and other evidence presented or considered, matters officially noticed, any findings of fact and conclusions of law proposed by any party, and any written brief filed.
6. Decision: Unless the designation of the Hearing Officer by the Chief Executive Officer provides otherwise, upon review of the record, the Hearing Officer shall prepare, file and serve upon each party his or her decision. Each decision shall include a statement of findings and conclusions upon all the material issues of fact, law, or discretion presented by the record and the appropriate order, sanction, relief, or denial.
E. Judicial Review: If a timely request for hearing is made, the decision of the Hearing Officer shall be a final order. Any party adversely affected by the decision of a Hearing Officer may appeal it to the District Court in and for the County of El Paso pursuant to rule 106(a)(4) of the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure. If the alleged violator fails to submit a timely written request for a hearing, the alleged violator has failed to exhaust administrative remedies and may not appeal the notice or order to District Court.
F. Judicial Collection: After the order assessing administrative fines has become final, or after a court in an action brought under subsection E of this section has entered a final judgment in favor of Utilities, the Chief Executive Officer may request the City Attorney to bring a civil action, if not earlier filed as a part of the judicial review, in the District Court to recover the amount assessed (plus postjudgment interest at the legal rate of interest, as defined at Colorado Revised Statutes section 5-12-101). In such an action, the validity, amount, and appropriateness of the penalty shall not be subject to review. (Ord. 99-163; Ord. 00-204; Ord. 01-42; Ord. 10-82; Ord. 18-42; Ord. 19-34)