35-1904. - Commercial design standards.
(1) Applicability:
(a) The following objective design standards shall be applied to all new commercial uses, developed individually or as part of a larger commercial center.
(b) These standards are intended to provide a clear set of architectural and site design requirements for new commercial development. These standards provide clear and quantifiable direction to ensure that future development maintains the unique character and high quality of design within the City of Chandler, while ensuring building form and scale are appropriate to the site.
(2) Site layout:
(a) Height, building setback, and lot coverage shall be regulated by the zoning district in which the property is located in. These regulations can be found in the City of Chandler Land Use and Zoning Code at the following links:
Commercial Zoning Districts | Code Section
Neighborhood Commercial District (C-1) | 35-1203
Community Commercial District (C-2) | 35-1303
Regional Commercial District (C-3) | 35-1403
Height and area regulations for lots located in Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning districts are established by the ordinance that adopted the PAD, which can be found in the development's zoning file. Zoning files are kept at the City of Chandler's Development Services Department.
When commercial projects are adjacent to a rear or side yard of single-family residential development, including those instances when separated by an alley, the following separation must be maintained on the site: Commerical buildings shall be no closer than twenty-five (25) feet, plus one (1) additional foot for each foot of height of the commercial building, from the residential property line.
(b) Stand-alone building PAD sites:
1. Applicability: For the purpose of this section, stand-alone building PAD sites are uses that stand apart from, and hence are not perceivable as, part of the main building complex. Stand-alone PAD sites may be developed as single freestanding uses, such as a restaurant or bank, or a cluster of uses sharing common architectural detail and materials, open spaces, and shaded areas and pedestrian connections. Freestanding building adjacent to the main complex structures will not be considered stand-alone building PAD sites if the freestanding building is not separated from the larger complex by vehicular movement, improved vehicular surfaces, or retention area.
2. Number: The number of PAD sites permissible in a shopping center shall be limited to one per arterial street frontage, with corner PAD sites to count as one of the frontage allowances. Multi-user PAD sites are permitted only when the uses are integrated and clustered within a common open space with seating areas and pedestrian walks, share common architectural details and materials (e.g., color, texture) portrayed by the main complex, and not separated by vehicular movement. More than two (2) freestanding PAD sites may be approved through the preliminary development plan (PDP) process.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Zoning Administrator may approve more than two (2) free-standing PAD sites per development administratively, upon determining that all of the following apply:
a. The PAD will enhance the quality of the overall development or revitalize an existing commercial center;
b. An additional PAD will make use of an area that is currently underutilized;
c. There is sufficient area on the site to accommodate safe and adequate on-site traffic circulation and the site has been designed to prevent drive-through queuing from backing onto main driveways or public streets;
d. No more than one high-turnover user per street frontage;
e. The PAD(s) and the overall commercial center in which it is located comply with Article XVIII parking and loading regulations;
f. The architectural design (i.e. building form and materials) of the PAD is compatible with and superior to existing buildings in the same center through the following but not limited to:
i. Increased levels of architectural quality;
ii. Greater material diversity;
iii. Enhanced usable space and/or pedestrian connection;
iv. Activation of street frontage;
v. Higher levels of landscape design;
vi. Creative design solutions for back-of-house functions.
3. Location: Any high-turnover uses (fast food, convenience stores, service stations, etc.) must be integrated within larger planned commercial and office centers. However, on sites where the contiguous area is generally insufficient to allow a larger planned center, relief may be considered through the provisions of the Planned Area Development (PAD) process, subject to approval by City Council.
4. Construction: Any stand-alone PAD site building(s) twelve thousand (12,000) square feet or greater in building area, located within any commercial site that is ten (10) acres or greater in size, shall be allowed to be constructed prior to the balance of the commercial center. Any PAD site buildings twenty-five thousand (25,000) square feet or less in building area, located within any commercial site that is less than ten (10) acres in size, shall be constructed concurrently or subsequently with at least twelve thousand (12,000) square feet of additional building area in the commercial center.
(c) Drive throughs and pick-up windows:
1. One drive-up or drive through user per street frontage is permissible as long as the drive-up does not conflict with parking maneuvering areas, main-stream vehicular movement, or in itself create an unsafe traffic situation.
2. All queuing lanes for fast food and similar high-turnover uses shall be a minimum of fourteen (14) feet in width.
3. Establishments with queuing lanes that offer on-site ordering shall meet all of the following requirements:
a. Provide at least one queuing lane meeting both of the following queuing length requirements:
i. Minimum one hundred fifty (150) feet in length measured from the drive-up window to the start of the lane;
ii. Minimum of one hundred twenty (120) feet from the start of the lane to the menu board.
b. Any additional queuing lanes shall not be counted towards the minimum queuing requirement for on-site ordering.
c. Any additional queuing lanes dedicated solely for picking up pre-ordered items and which do not have a menu board shall provide a minimum of sixty (60) feet in length measured from the pickup window to start of the lane. This queuing length standard is not intended for such uses as drug stores, banks, dry cleaners, etc.
4. Drive through lane entry and exit shall be separated from vehicular parking areas, through curbing, landscaping, etc.
5. At each intersection of drive through lanes and sidewalks, a crosswalk with textured, decorative paving and pedestrian crossing signs shall be provided. Additionally, one of the following safety measures shall be provided:
a. Crosswalk with raised speed table;
b. Speed bump prior to pedestrian crosswalk.
6. All drive through facilities, including drive through lanes and queuing areas shall be adequately screened from street view by building orientation, or by a landscaped berm and retaining wall measuring four (4) feet from grade of the driving lane, and situated so as not to disrupt safe traffic flow.
7. Drive through speaker(s) shall not face property zoned for single-family residential uses.
8. Menu boards shall be screened from street view by building orientation or by a minimum 4-foot solid masonry wall.
(d) Pedestrian connectivity:
1. An on-site walkway shall connect the main entry of each building or each primary entry to a public sidewalk on each street frontage of the site, and to any transit stop adjacent to the site.
2. A system of pedestrian walkways shall connect all buildings on a site to each other, to on-site automobile and bicycle parking areas, and to any on-site recreational or open space areas or pedestrian amenities.
3. Textured paving treatments shall be provided at all on-site pedestrian crosswalks, and driveway entrances for a minimum of thirty (30) feet in length on-site.
4. Bus bay locations, where applicable, shall be integrated with pedestrian walkways that provide direct access to the property.
5. Perimeter sidewalks shall be provided in one of the following manners:
a. Detached and separated from the curb by landscaping barrier;
b. Attached to the curb;
c. Entirely or partially meandering and detached and separated from the curb by landscaping barrier.
6. Perimeter sidewalks shall connect to existing perimeter sidewalks on abutting properties.
7. Perimeter sidewalks shall be not less than six (6) feet in width except that, in locations anticipating heavier than normal pedestrian traffic, the zoning administrator may require these to be eight (8) feet in width.
(3) Building architecture:
(a) Massing and articulation:
1. Horizontal off sets:
i. Buildings less than two thousand (2,000) square feet shall incorporate breaks in massing having a depth of at least six (6) inches for a minimum of twenty-five percent (25%) of each building elevation through the use of varying setbacks, building entries, exterior wall plane offset, or modulation of building facades.
ii. Buildings greater than two thousand (2,000) square feet shall incorporate breaks in massing having a depth of at least two (2) feet for a minimum of twenty-five percent (25%) of each building elevation through the use of varying setbacks, building entries, building offset, or modulation of building facades.
2. Vertical variation: Change in rooflines of at least two (2) feet in height shall be provided for a minimum of twenty-five percent (25%) of each building elevation through change in height and form.
3. The Zoning Administrator may accept minor departures from the horizontal off set and vertical variation requirements for the rear elevations of a building that are not visible from public rights-of-way or adjoining residential, commercial, or open spaces.
(b) Architectural consistency:
1. Building architecture shall promote consistent architectural character and detail on all sides of the structure, including the continued use of building materials on each side.
2. If a subject site is located within a larger existing center or development, then the subject site shall be architecturally integrated with the larger center or development. To be considered architecturally integrated, the proposal shall provide the following at minimum:
i. The predominant building color(s) (excluding accent colors) used on the proposed building shall match the predominant building color(s) found in the larger center.
ii. The predominant building materials used on the proposed building shall feature at least two (2) prominent building materials found in the larger center.
iii. The predominant roof form and roof materials on the proposed building shall use the same predominant roof form and roof materials found in the center.
3. Building features that are used for advertising or to promote a recognizable corporate image (corporate stylized architecture) shall be limited to a maximum of one accent color or material and shall meet one of the following:
i. When the color or material is not found within the approved color palate for the larger center, then the color or material shall be limited to ten percent (10%) of a single building elevation.
ii. When the color or material is found within the approved color palate for the larger center, then the color or material shall be limited twenty percent (20%) of a single building elevation. additional colors or materials may be considered if they are prominent building colors found within the approved color palate for the center.
(c) Building materials and facade details:
1. Building materials shall be of high quality and durable. they include, but are not limited to:
i. Brick
ii. Stone (natural or faux)
iii. Integral color, sand blasted or stain textured masonry
iv. Split-faced masonry units
v. Tilt-up concrete panels
vi. Stucco/EIFS
vii. Architectural pre-finished metal
viii. Concrete and clay tile roofs
ix. Treated or engineered wood product
2. At least three (3) materials shall be used in addition to glazing and accent features (e.g., fence panels, tile accents, trellises) unless dictated by an architectural style that prescribes a particular building material as the dominant feature (e.g., pueblo, santa fe style, etc.) as follows:
i. A predominant material (maximum sixty-five percent (65%)) and two (2) additional materials (minimum ten percent (10%) each) shall be provided on each building facade
3. Solid covered canopies shall be provided at all pedestrian building entries at a minimum depth of four (4) feet.
4. Where existing flush curbing is utilized, a combination of decorative bollards and landscape planters shall be provided with no more than six (6) consecutive bollards.
(d) Screening:
1. Any commercial development using outside storage area for equipment, vehicles, or materials shall screen such area from view with a 6-foot masonry or concrete wall excluding approved gated openings.
2. Dismantling, servicing, repairing, etc., of vehicles and/or equipment shall be within completely enclosed buildings or within an area enclosed by a solid concrete, masonry, or similar material wall except for openings for ingress and egress which shall be furnished with solid gates.
3. Service bays shall meet all of the following screening requirements:
i. Screening from adjacent properties zoned for residential uses shall meet the following requirements:
1) Bay doors located within one hundred (100) feet of an adjacent residential property line shall be oriented away from the adjacent use.
2) Bay doors located between one hundred (100) feet and six hundred (600) feet of an adjacent residential property line and oriented such that the bay doors would be visible from the adjacent use shall be screened with an intervening building or an 8-foot-tall screen wall. The 8-foot-tall screen wall shall not be located in the required building setback.
ii. Screening from adjacent streets shall be accomplished through the use of intervening building such that the bay doors are not visible from the street(s). Sites that are unable to screen service bays using an intervening building shall use at minimum one of the following methods:
1) Preferred method: Orient the building such that the bay doors are perpendicular to the abutting street. For corner lots, the bay doors shall be oriented perpendicular to the street with the highest functional street classification (i.e. arterial, collector, etc.) identified in the general plan. in the event that the street classifications are equivalent, the orientation creating the smallest noise impact on adjacent residential development shall be used.
2) Bay doors facing the street shall be setback at least two hundred (200) feet.
3) Bay doors less than two hundred (200) feet from an adjacent street and less than perpendicular to a street shall provide a solid 6-foot masonry screen wall. The 6-foot-tall screen wall shall not be located in the required building setback.
4. Provide long-term storage of shopping carts either within the tenant space or adjacent to it, behind a decorative screen wall exceeding the height of the carts. Shopping cart storage shall not encroach into accessible pathways.
(e) Gas stations:
1. Design of gas canopies shall be integrated with adjacent building architecture through the use of similar materials, colors, and roof forms.
2. Gas canopy lights shall be flush with the bottom of canopy.
3. Gas canopy bottom edge shall be a maximum of fifteen (15) feet six (6) inches above finish grade, unless canopy is integrated into convenience store building.
4. All venting and mechanical equipment shall be screened from arterial streets and public view, this includes gas vent stacks. Gas vents shall be integrated into the canopy or mounted directly adjacent to the convenience store and shall not be a separate structure. The canopy shall incorporate alternative materials (such as louvers or mesh screening) to allow for sufficient ventilation while fully screening any gas vents or mechanical equipment.
5. No outside vending is permitted, including ice machines.
(f) Interface with single-family residential area: When commercial projects are next to or across an alley from a rear or side yard of single-family residential development:
1. Second-story window balconies and other openings are allowed only when demonstrated to and approved by the zoning administrator that back yards of adjacent residences will not be visible from such balconies or openings by persons sitting or standing in the commercial buildings.
(4) Locational criteria and site development standards for large single use retail development:
(a) Locational criteria: Large single use retail, as defined in section 35-200 of this Code, shall only be permitted on property zoned as Planned Area Development (PAD) for such use, in accordance with the requirements and provisions of Chapter 35, Article XVII of this Code, and further subject to all of the following location criteria. Any proposal to expand an existing retail use, which subsequently brings the total building coverage of that use to one hundred fifty thousand (150,000) square feet or more, shall also require conformance with all of the following standards, for the entire site development. Council may approve departure from these standards upon finding that such departure is warranted, based upon consideration of mitigating circumstances, design innovation, or other meritorious feature(s), as provided for in Chapter 35, Article XVII of this Code.
1. Any parcel proposed for a large single use retail development shall be adjacent to a freeway interchange, or shall front along two (2) major arterials forming an intersection designated by the Chandler General Plan as "commercial node," or as "regional major commercial development," or other successor designation specified in the general plan, or in an area plan approved by the Mayor and City Council, that expressly provides for such large single use retail development.
2. A minimum distance of one thousand five hundred (1,500) feet, as measured on a straight line, shall be required from the nearest property line of any parcel currently zoned for low density single-family residential use, to the nearest exterior wall of the large single use retail building.
a. For purposes of this measurement, the phrase "low density single-family residential use" shall mean a subdivision of land, as defined in section 35-200 of this Code, located within the City jurisdiction, with a net overall density in the range of zero to four and one-half dwelling units/acre. For purposes of this measurement, neither the AG-1 (agriculture) nor the MH-1 (mobile home) zoning district shall be considered as a low density single-family zoning designation.
b. The one thousand five hundred (1,500) foot distance may be reduced or waived altogether by Council if based upon a finding that other mitigating circumstances already exist on, or adjacent to, the site proposed for large single use retail development. Such mitigating circumstances may involve existing non-single-family land uses or zoning designations, or other physical barriers such as a major arterial right-of-way, freeway right-of-way, railroad or canal right-of-way, which Council may find achieves an effective separation and buffer from the land use impacts of the large single use retail development.
c. The one thousand five hundred (1,500) foot distance may be reduced, or waived altogether, by Council if based upon a finding that the large single use retail development proposal demonstrates a combination of superior architectural or site design techniques, such as, without limitation, i) attaching other accessory retail shop space and storefronts to displace at least a portion of what would otherwise be a lengthy exterior front wall plane of the large single use retail building; ii) extensive greenbelts not less than one hundred (100) feet in width that feature mature landscaping, architectural theme walls, and terraces that cause the finished grade of the large single use retail building to be at least six (6) feet lower than the finished lot grade of the nearest low density single-family residential use; iii) relocation of loading docks and overhead bay doors to another side of the building which does not face any adjacent residential use, and which in turn causes elimination of any rear service drive or other means of access to the rear of the building other than pedestrian doors; iv) completely separating the large single use retail building with smaller scale buildings accommodating less intensive land use(s), which provides an effective transition to any adjoining residential use.
The requirements of this subsection 35-1904(4)(a)2. shall not apply if the developer of such low density single-family residential use was required by condition of zoning as approved by the Chandler City Council to give full and adequate disclosure that said residential subdivision was within one thousand five hundred (1,500) feet to another site currently designated for regional commercial use, as shown on the Chandler General Plan, wherein such designation may permit large single use retail development.
3. An application requesting zoning approval for a large single use retail component may also request zoning for a single-family use as a component of a mixed use project only when each of the following conditions are met:
a. The large single use retail parcel shall be expressly identified for such use as part of a mixed use Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning application, wherein such application as approved by City Council also depicts the single-family residential parcel(s), and any transitional land use parcels and buffers adjoining the large single use retail parcel.
b. Full and adequate disclosure of such large single use retail location shall be given by the developer or homebuilder of the single-family residential use within one thousand five hundred (1,500) feet, to any prospective homebuyer in the manner specified as a condition of City Council approval, for the Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning application.
c. Preliminary development plan approval for the large single use retail parcel, in the manner set forth in section 35-1706 of this Code, shall be required either prior to, or concurrent with, preliminary development plan approval for one or more single-family residential parcels within said mixed use development proposal.
d. The required Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning application, wherein such mixed uses are identified, shall also demonstrate sufficient buffer separations using such elements as street right-of-way, stormwater retention area(s), landscaping techniques, and masonry walls, in combination to achieve complete separation. In no event shall any parcel proposed for large single use retail, share a property line with any parcel proposed for low density single-family use.
4. Any parcel proposed for large single use retail development shall be a minimum distance of one thousand three hundred (1,300) feet from any site currently zoned, or built, as a public or private elementary school, middle school, junior high, or high school.
a. In no event shall any development site containing a large single use retail parcel gain vehicular access from a local street, collector street, or private drive, that also provides vehicular access or frontage to a public or private elementary school, middle school, junior high, or high school.
b. The minimum distances required by this subsection 35-1904(3)(a)4., between the large single use retail building and any given school, shall be the shortest straight line measurement from the school property line to the nearest exterior wall of the large single use retail building.
The requirements of this subsection 35-1904(4)(a)4. shall not apply to any elementary school, middle school, junior high, or high school located on property zoned for uses other than low density single-family residential use.
Notwithstanding conformance with all of the above locational criteria, City Council may deny an application for the Planned Area Development (PAD) zoning designation, in accordance with the provisions set forth in section 35-1706(4) of this Code.
(b) Site development standards: In addition to the site development and landscaping standards set forth in Article XIX of this Code, large single use retail shall also be subject to conformance with the following additional standards. Council may approve departure from these standards upon finding that such departure is warranted, based upon design innovation or other meritorious feature(s) as provided for in Chapter 35, Article XVII of this Code:
1. Maximum total site coverage of all buildings shall not exceed twenty-four percent (24%) of the net site area.
2. Minimum front, side, and rear setbacks for all large single use retail building(s) and parking, as otherwise specified in section 35-1902 of this Code, shall be increased at the rate of two (2) additional feet for each ten thousand (10,000) square feet of building coverage over one hundred fifty thousand (150,000) square feet. Such setbacks from any public street shall be measured from the future right-of-way line, wherein such right-of-way width is determined in accordance with the circulation element of the Chandler General Plan.
3. The architecture of the large single use retail building, together with any PAD building(s) or in-line shops, shall demonstrate visual interest on all exterior sides through the use of such techniques, without limitation, as wall plane changes, color and material changes, pop-outs, reveal lines, scoring, varied roof lines and slopes, recessed features, articulated customer entrances, canopies, colonnades, and other elements, all of which effectively integrate the building mass with its surroundings, and bring proportion to its horizontal and vertical dimensions.
4. Entry drives shall be aligned with any point of access to an arterial street that provides full turning movements, as approved by the City Transportation Engineer. Said entry drive(s) shall be defined as a boulevard, thereby separating entry/exiting movements from parking space search maneuvers.
5. Sidewalks not less than six (6) feet in width shall be provided within the site development, providing direct pedestrian access from the arterial sidewalks to primary customer entry doors. Such on-site sidewalks shall be separate and distinct by use of landscaping, color, and material changes. In addition, a minimum ten (10) foot wide sidewalk shall be provided parallel to the front elevation of the large single use retail building for its entire length, and separate from any parking space overhang, driving aisle or landscaping as required in section 35-1906 of this Code.
6. Any outdoor display areas for merchandise shall be enclosed by fence walls integrated with the architecture, color, and materials of the primary building, and may include wrought iron for visibility. Such fence wall enclosures shall be a minimum four (4) feet or greater in height.
7. Any areas used for shopping cart containment as may be provided adjacent to the building, shall be fully enclosed and screened by a minimum four (4) foot high masonry wall, with berming and landscaping in the quantities set forth in section 35-1906 of this Code.
8. Outdoor storage of merchandise or other miscellaneous material, including containment in metal bins, shall not displace any portion of the site development intended for parking, access, landscaping, or loading, and shall be screened in the manner specified in section 35-1904(3)(d)1. and 35-1905(3)(e)1v. of this Code.
9. A traffic study shall be submitted for approval by the City Transportation Engineer, in conjunction with the preliminary development plan submittal requirements set forth in section 35-1706 of this Code. Recommended measures and improvements to mitigate traffic impacts shall be the responsibility of the project developer.
10. A photometric plan shall be submitted for approval by the Zoning Administrator, in conjunction with the preliminary development plan requirements set forth in section 35-1706 of this Code. Said plan shall demonstrate an illumination level in the range of 1.5 to 2.0 footcandles, for approval by the Chief of Police or designee. Such submittal shall include catalogue cuts of all lighting fixtures with shields to ensure down lighting only, concealed point sources of light, and prevent overspill onto adjoining properties.
11. Overnight parking of recreational vehicles anywhere within the site development shall be prohibited.
(Ord. No. 5142, § 2(Exh. A), 11-13-25)